The problem is the digital format. If it was a physical game disc and they put it on a huge sale for a weekend then even scalpers would only be able to get ahold of so many. Resellers can buy thousands of keys at the sale price to resell after the sale ends.
It’s a bit hilarious you’re calling me a capitalist bootlicker while defending whats basically private equity reseller companies that exist only to leech off of others labor, turning them having one time sales into a constant stream of revenue for assholes.
Maybe you got lost, but the ml instance is over that way somewhere.
It’s up to them to figure out solutions that don’t fuck over regular consumers. Steam doesn’t get to be the only legal storefront. It’s bad enough that we only get a license but I don’t get defending this when it’s clearly anti consumer above all else. I figured most people on Lemmy would like to properly own their games, it seems like a hot button issue. This is the opposite of that, a feature that takes advantage of the fact that we don’t own the game.
If you buy a product, it should become yours and you should be able to do whatever you want with it. It doesn’t matter if you bought it from a reseller or on sale or wtv.
Some people seem to have gotten their keys removed even when they bought it from a reseller that got it directly from the publisher, nothing shady about it.
I don’t think it’s scalping. Scalping has scarcity involved to drive up the price, this is the opposite.
It’s not scalping. The keysellers are what fuck over regular consumers. Steam sales used to be known for their crazy discounts, but as soon as keysellers began buying thousands of keys at those sale prices and then reselling them for a profit that pretty much died and now it often takes years for well selling games to get a decent discount.
This has nothing to do with Steam being the only legal store front. It doesn’t matter how many legitimate store fronts there are, if key resellers scum profit for themselves out of a game ever having a sale on any of them then those sales stop happening.
Of course if you buy a product you should own it, but if you buy it from some guy in an alley wearing a trench coat for 20% of the actual price then you don’t get to be surprised when the thing doesn’t work. It doesn’t matter if it’s software or hardware, when you see something being sold for a fraction of the price the actual creator sells it for at a place that isn’t an official store front there’s a reason for that and that reason might be that it’s stolen and effectively worthless. If you don’t buy from the creator or an official seller of their product then you don’t have the right to complain to them. It’s not Nintendo’s fault you bought a stolen Switch 2 of of a social media ad and they bricked it because it was reported stolen by the actual owner.
The problem is that it isn’t stolen, counterfeit or anything if the sort.
Buying on sale is perfectly legal. On top of that, in this case, they also banned keys that the publisher sold directly to a reseller, not a reseller that bought it on sale pretending to be a regular customer. Granted, they are going back on that and it was largely a mistake, it just shows exactly what’s wrong with all this.
The fact is that if a key is sold by the publisher and ends up in my possession, and I activate it and it’s valid since it was bought legally and is an official key, then that’s the end of it.
They shouldn’t get to have a say in the transactions along the way. The whole reasoning for it is petty excuses. It doesn’t matter the effects, they can find solutions that don’t associate massive risks with using second hand shops for fuck sakes.
You know that bullshit where if you buy a second hand Tesla, a bunch of the software stops working even though it has a lifetime membership since its associated with the person and not the car, this is the exact same kind of bullshit.
We should be able to turn our games into keys whenever we want and trade them with friends ffs. Why are you advocating for taking keys offline just because of who’s hand it went through when they were bought perfectly legally?
Why are you advocating for taking keys offline just because of who’s hand it went through when they were bought perfectly legally?
Buying keys on Steam to resell them is directly against their policy specifically so that developers feel comfortable putting products on sale. If a key was purchased by a reseller from Steam then they can legally use it, however they can’t resell it. Many do. They’re the one doing something wrong and fucking people over, in order to insert themselves as an unofficial middle man and leech money.
You are defending a wrong (taking perfectly valid keys offline) because of a group abusing it in a legal manner (buying excess keys).
They could find solutions that don’t spit on our ownership rights.
It’s ToS abuse imo, not really defendable. Steam is getting dragged into court because of shit like this. The breach of ethics involved in trying to dictate the use of keys is far greater than the one committed by the reseller imo. They can only do this because of the quasi monopoly they have.
I really think this is the steam pink google effect. If it was Microsoft and Activision behind it, everyone would be livid imo.
I don’t have some strange love for Steam. It was the dev who decided to do it, and the people need to get a refund through the storefront they chose to use.
There aren’t any tools. They shouldn’t get to control what happens after they sell it. They sold it, they chose the price, end of story.
Try to apply the same logic to GameStop and not sound like a capitalist bootlicker. If Activision was pulling this, you’d be seething at the mouth.
The problem is the digital format. If it was a physical game disc and they put it on a huge sale for a weekend then even scalpers would only be able to get ahold of so many. Resellers can buy thousands of keys at the sale price to resell after the sale ends.
It’s a bit hilarious you’re calling me a capitalist bootlicker while defending whats basically private equity reseller companies that exist only to leech off of others labor, turning them having one time sales into a constant stream of revenue for assholes.
Maybe you got lost, but the ml instance is over that way somewhere.
It’s up to them to figure out solutions that don’t fuck over regular consumers. Steam doesn’t get to be the only legal storefront. It’s bad enough that we only get a license but I don’t get defending this when it’s clearly anti consumer above all else. I figured most people on Lemmy would like to properly own their games, it seems like a hot button issue. This is the opposite of that, a feature that takes advantage of the fact that we don’t own the game.
If you buy a product, it should become yours and you should be able to do whatever you want with it. It doesn’t matter if you bought it from a reseller or on sale or wtv.
Some people seem to have gotten their keys removed even when they bought it from a reseller that got it directly from the publisher, nothing shady about it.
I don’t think it’s scalping. Scalping has scarcity involved to drive up the price, this is the opposite.
It’s not scalping. The keysellers are what fuck over regular consumers. Steam sales used to be known for their crazy discounts, but as soon as keysellers began buying thousands of keys at those sale prices and then reselling them for a profit that pretty much died and now it often takes years for well selling games to get a decent discount.
This has nothing to do with Steam being the only legal store front. It doesn’t matter how many legitimate store fronts there are, if key resellers scum profit for themselves out of a game ever having a sale on any of them then those sales stop happening.
Of course if you buy a product you should own it, but if you buy it from some guy in an alley wearing a trench coat for 20% of the actual price then you don’t get to be surprised when the thing doesn’t work. It doesn’t matter if it’s software or hardware, when you see something being sold for a fraction of the price the actual creator sells it for at a place that isn’t an official store front there’s a reason for that and that reason might be that it’s stolen and effectively worthless. If you don’t buy from the creator or an official seller of their product then you don’t have the right to complain to them. It’s not Nintendo’s fault you bought a stolen Switch 2 of of a social media ad and they bricked it because it was reported stolen by the actual owner.
The problem is that it isn’t stolen, counterfeit or anything if the sort.
Buying on sale is perfectly legal. On top of that, in this case, they also banned keys that the publisher sold directly to a reseller, not a reseller that bought it on sale pretending to be a regular customer. Granted, they are going back on that and it was largely a mistake, it just shows exactly what’s wrong with all this.
The fact is that if a key is sold by the publisher and ends up in my possession, and I activate it and it’s valid since it was bought legally and is an official key, then that’s the end of it.
They shouldn’t get to have a say in the transactions along the way. The whole reasoning for it is petty excuses. It doesn’t matter the effects, they can find solutions that don’t associate massive risks with using second hand shops for fuck sakes.
You know that bullshit where if you buy a second hand Tesla, a bunch of the software stops working even though it has a lifetime membership since its associated with the person and not the car, this is the exact same kind of bullshit.
We should be able to turn our games into keys whenever we want and trade them with friends ffs. Why are you advocating for taking keys offline just because of who’s hand it went through when they were bought perfectly legally?
Buying keys on Steam to resell them is directly against their policy specifically so that developers feel comfortable putting products on sale. If a key was purchased by a reseller from Steam then they can legally use it, however they can’t resell it. Many do. They’re the one doing something wrong and fucking people over, in order to insert themselves as an unofficial middle man and leech money.
You are defending a wrong (taking perfectly valid keys offline) because of a group abusing it in a legal manner (buying excess keys).
They could find solutions that don’t spit on our ownership rights.
It’s ToS abuse imo, not really defendable. Steam is getting dragged into court because of shit like this. The breach of ethics involved in trying to dictate the use of keys is far greater than the one committed by the reseller imo. They can only do this because of the quasi monopoly they have.
I really think this is the steam pink google effect. If it was Microsoft and Activision behind it, everyone would be livid imo.
I don’t have some strange love for Steam. It was the dev who decided to do it, and the people need to get a refund through the storefront they chose to use.