This is pretty good as a joke, but imagine this as a horror story. Here you are hiking a notoriously remote and dangerous mountainside and you come around a bend to find a man casually waiting in your path. Dressed for the office, carrying an umbrella, wholly unequipped for this location but looking for all the world like he just showered, shaved, dressed, and walked to the bus stop on the corner. This clothes, his posture, his expression say nothing of the week long hike it took you to get here, he smells of freshly applied cologne. He glances at you with the benal expression of the Thursday office grind, too early to be excited about Friday, to late to really care about the events of the week, and steps slightly to the side and back as if making space to form a queue as he waits. If he recognizes you, he makes no expression of it, nor does he react to the look of terror you fail to hide when you see he is identical to you, not in the way that a mirror image is, but in that slightly wrong way that forward facing cameras flip the image.
Do you pass him, daring to get close enough to do so? Do you turn around and risk putting your back to this thing? Do you join yourself in queue? No answer truely seems appropriate.
I read, and can’t stop wondering if I would be scared or intrigued more. I think such a meeting could become an interesting conversation, apart from perchance being a hallucination from dying of exhaustion
I find these thought experiments important for understanding one’s self. Personally it’s on sight with anything that looks too much like me, I’m not going to humour a Doppelganger’s attempts to replace me. Cursed objects on the other hand, that’s like catnip for me. Haunted doll? It’s mine. Cursed puzzle box? You bet. Book bound in human skin and inked in blood? That’s going right on the coffee table. I will ship of Theseus haunted houses until I find every part that contains ghost and then use all of that to build a new 100% haunted house.
This is pretty good as a joke, but imagine this as a horror story. Here you are hiking a notoriously remote and dangerous mountainside and you come around a bend to find a man casually waiting in your path. Dressed for the office, carrying an umbrella, wholly unequipped for this location but looking for all the world like he just showered, shaved, dressed, and walked to the bus stop on the corner. This clothes, his posture, his expression say nothing of the week long hike it took you to get here, he smells of freshly applied cologne. He glances at you with the benal expression of the Thursday office grind, too early to be excited about Friday, to late to really care about the events of the week, and steps slightly to the side and back as if making space to form a queue as he waits. If he recognizes you, he makes no expression of it, nor does he react to the look of terror you fail to hide when you see he is identical to you, not in the way that a mirror image is, but in that slightly wrong way that forward facing cameras flip the image.
Do you pass him, daring to get close enough to do so? Do you turn around and risk putting your back to this thing? Do you join yourself in queue? No answer truely seems appropriate.
Sounds like this could be an episode of The Twilight Zone!
It’s happened before:
https://youtube.com/shorts/gbZ4ucfMDs0
Sorry but that title is so shitty I can not click it.
Now I want you to write the full story so I can read it. The premise is definitely a great launchpad and the style of your approach to it works great.
If I had the chops to actually write a full story, I’d gladly send it your way.
I read, and can’t stop wondering if I would be scared or intrigued more. I think such a meeting could become an interesting conversation, apart from perchance being a hallucination from dying of exhaustion
I find these thought experiments important for understanding one’s self. Personally it’s on sight with anything that looks too much like me, I’m not going to humour a Doppelganger’s attempts to replace me. Cursed objects on the other hand, that’s like catnip for me. Haunted doll? It’s mine. Cursed puzzle box? You bet. Book bound in human skin and inked in blood? That’s going right on the coffee table. I will ship of Theseus haunted houses until I find every part that contains ghost and then use all of that to build a new 100% haunted house.