I take it you view anti-natalism as eco-fascism, even if it ideologically doesn’t even bring up environmental damage?
I agree that humans are part of nature, and that viewing humans as a plague on nature is dumb. I however do not see the positive of continuing our species, for the very individual’s within it. None of us consent to being born, and if only 1 in a million find their existence to be undesirable (and its a way way worse rate than that) then giving birth to a single person is rolling the dice on bringing about unjust suffering and is unethical.
I don’t view anti-natalism as inherently eco-fascist, no. I said what I did because the person I was responding to directly brought up environmental damage.
That said, I don’t personally agree with anti-natalism as applied on any level larger than personal. There is no world in which a fetus of any species could ever consent to being born. Does that mean all life should cease to exist on principal?
I still believe that a person’s reproductive choice should always be their own. If that leads to the extinction of our species, then at least it’s what we collectively chose for ourselves. But I find it frankly insulting to women who want children to act like bringing them into the world is a morally unjust thing to do. In the same way, I view it insulting to women who wish to remain childless to act like not having children is morally unjust.
I truly feel there should be no moral imperative for anyone to have or not have children.
There is no world in which a fetus of any species could ever consent to being born. Does that mean all life should cease to exist on principal?
Yes. (Under ideal conditions at least, life exists already though, I’m not a believer in efilism)
I still believe that a person’s reproductive choice should always be their own. If that leads to the extinction of our species, then at least it’s what we collectively chose for ourselves. But I find it frankly insulting to women who want children to act like bringing them into the world is a morally unjust thing to do. In the same way, I view it insulting to women who wish to remain childless to act like not having children is morally unjust.
Understandable from a women’s rights perspective, if you think that is what this is. However, my issue isn’t with whether specifically a woman chooses to have a child. Men can also want children and its also their choice as to whether they want to impregnate a woman. At least in so far that they do or do not engage in preventative methods with sexual activity.
I find both equally disagreeable, ethically.
I truly feel there should be no moral imperative for anyone to have or not have children.
I take it you view anti-natalism as eco-fascism, even if it ideologically doesn’t even bring up environmental damage?
I agree that humans are part of nature, and that viewing humans as a plague on nature is dumb. I however do not see the positive of continuing our species, for the very individual’s within it. None of us consent to being born, and if only 1 in a million find their existence to be undesirable (and its a way way worse rate than that) then giving birth to a single person is rolling the dice on bringing about unjust suffering and is unethical.
But yeah, Human’s aren’t a plague.
I don’t view anti-natalism as inherently eco-fascist, no. I said what I did because the person I was responding to directly brought up environmental damage.
That said, I don’t personally agree with anti-natalism as applied on any level larger than personal. There is no world in which a fetus of any species could ever consent to being born. Does that mean all life should cease to exist on principal?
I still believe that a person’s reproductive choice should always be their own. If that leads to the extinction of our species, then at least it’s what we collectively chose for ourselves. But I find it frankly insulting to women who want children to act like bringing them into the world is a morally unjust thing to do. In the same way, I view it insulting to women who wish to remain childless to act like not having children is morally unjust.
I truly feel there should be no moral imperative for anyone to have or not have children.
Yes. (Under ideal conditions at least, life exists already though, I’m not a believer in efilism)
Understandable from a women’s rights perspective, if you think that is what this is. However, my issue isn’t with whether specifically a woman chooses to have a child. Men can also want children and its also their choice as to whether they want to impregnate a woman. At least in so far that they do or do not engage in preventative methods with sexual activity.
I find both equally disagreeable, ethically.
Do you think having children is harmless?