So I love worldbuilding and have been working on a years-long passion project. I decided to use it in a campaign but a player really took issue with some of my choices with races.

I understand that having a race of wholly evil individuals can be an issue. But what if they universally have some kind of trait that isnt necessarily good or evil? For example, I have a race of what would appear to be tieflings, but occupy the space that elves might in Tolkien. One of their characteristics is that they physically change throughout the year. Their hair might change color. they may become stronger. Their magic may be more potent. Their physiology is linked to the state of the forest around them

I also have a race of lizard people. They aren’t super complicated. They just live in the lizard people country because the conditions there suit lizard people needs more than other races.

Would these things make me guilty of some sort of essentialism?

  • themeatbridge
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    7 hours ago

    I think it has more to do with how you treat those characters. Are they one-dimensional caricatures existing to serve the plot?

    • aedaz@lemmy.zipOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      7 hours ago

      I mean if they’re one dimmensional, it’ll be because im not a good writer. I’m not out to make a caricature of anything. I just get ideas i think are neat and try to do something with them. But my player seems to be taking an ethical issue with giving unique traits to races at all.