• shalafi
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    2 days ago

    An interesting question that’s never addressed in these debates:

    If a person born with a male body is taking hormones to make them female, shouldn’t they be weaker and slower? Either gender change makes a difference or it does not. Pick. One.

    • Delphia
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      2 days ago

      It is and has been addressed.

      The issue is that if you transition from male to female at 21 you have had 21 years of male growth hormones guiding your musculature and skeletal development. After a few years on estrogen you wont be as fast or strong as a cisgender man but you cant give up the inherent power advantage you might have from a few extra inches in height and the extra pounds of muscle mass over a cisgender woman. Now the flip side to that argument is if you were a 5’4 140lb man before you transitioned theres not a great deal of performance advantage to be had.

      You coule solve the issue with body composition scans, if a trans womans body composition is within a reasonable range of the cisgender average then anyone who has a problem with them competing needs to STFU. That becomes very sticky though when you have someone who does have an arguable performance advantage due to having transitioned after puberty.