He’s not commenting on the otter or the salmon’s morality. They are (fairly) amoral agents in the situation. He is commenting on the situation itself.
A creator god would be an entity capable of morals. Forcing an amoral entity (the otter) to perform an immoral act (killing the salmon) is itself immoral. That immorality reflects on the creator, not the victims.
Humans are capable of morality ourselves. It could be argued that if humans are then immoral, it is a reflection on us, and our free will, not the creator. An otter is amoral, the creator can’t pass the buck to it for the deed.
Oh, and remember that this is within the discworld universe, not ours. In a later book you actually meet the creator god. His morality is definitely… limited.
He’s not commenting on the otter or the salmon’s morality. They are (fairly) amoral agents in the situation. He is commenting on the situation itself.
A creator god would be an entity capable of morals. Forcing an amoral entity (the otter) to perform an immoral act (killing the salmon) is itself immoral. That immorality reflects on the creator, not the victims.
Humans are capable of morality ourselves. It could be argued that if humans are then immoral, it is a reflection on us, and our free will, not the creator. An otter is amoral, the creator can’t pass the buck to it for the deed.
Oh, and remember that this is within the discworld universe, not ours. In a later book you actually meet the creator god. His morality is definitely… limited.