While I am not exactly pro-theft, I will say that your argument is structurally and conceptually wrong.
Competition drives prices down, demand drives prices up. Companies will always charge as much as they can get away with. They will raise the price to the maximum the market can bear even without theft. The only effect that theft might have on prices is to lower them. With enough theft demand will drop therefore the market will not bear the same high prices.
While I am not exactly pro-theft, I will say that your argument is structurally and conceptually wrong.
Competition drives prices down, demand drives prices up. Companies will always charge as much as they can get away with. They will raise the price to the maximum the market can bear even without theft. The only effect that theft might have on prices is to lower them. With enough theft demand will drop therefore the market will not bear the same high prices.