You are right, they were there to destroy fascism. This liberated jews. I did not say they did all that to liberate jews I said they were responsible for liberating European jews from fascism. I never claimed that it was their motive, I just claimed that it was something they did.
I disagree. Fascists were allowed to live and some remained in power but the structure of fascism was dismantled. Fascists just happen to make very good imperialists.
The Molotov Ribbentrop pact was a delay tactic used by the soviets to prepare for war with Nazi Germany. Please read any internal soviet records I am begging you. The Soviets knew they would end up fighting an existentional war with the Nazis in the early 1930s. When a party comes to full power based on the rhetoric that Bolshevism is the greatest enemy to man kind and needs to be destroyed entirely no reasonable Bolshevik thinks hmm yes this is my friend. The Soviets were not fucking stupid. The USSR tried to make a defensive alliance with literally everyone else against Germany and where the last to sign a pact with the Nazis. Partitioning Poland was a defensive move. Even my deeply conservative anti-communist European history professor admitted this. Please read actual scholarship that isn’t funded by the Hoover institute or similar organizations. People like Kotkin and Conquest are not reliable sources.
That’s a very convenient excuse and records are only as good as the people that keep them and the soviets were well known to doctor and forge documents and evidence.
You assume I haven’t read rather than I have but I simply disagree with you.
I’m aware no one wanted to help the soviets, no one had to but to say oh they joined the devil to lead the revolt from behind the front lines is absurd. You don’t get points for not being able to reign in your bullshit long enough for people to give a shit about you and yeah that applies just as well today as it did then.
They weren’t there to liberate Jews, no one was there to do that don’t be naive.
You are right, they were there to destroy fascism. This liberated jews. I did not say they did all that to liberate jews I said they were responsible for liberating European jews from fascism. I never claimed that it was their motive, I just claimed that it was something they did.
They were there to destroy the Germans. Which they did mostly by themselves.
They didn’t destroy or defeat fascism in any way. Fascism not only survived, but thanks to the US, it flourished.
I disagree. Fascists were allowed to live and some remained in power but the structure of fascism was dismantled. Fascists just happen to make very good imperialists.
Wrong again and perhaps even more naive.
It would be weird to agree to partition Poland with the people you would like eliminated huh?
Everyone has their reasons for being there or not but none of them were to destroy fascism, that’s just propaganda.
The Molotov Ribbentrop pact was a delay tactic used by the soviets to prepare for war with Nazi Germany. Please read any internal soviet records I am begging you. The Soviets knew they would end up fighting an existentional war with the Nazis in the early 1930s. When a party comes to full power based on the rhetoric that Bolshevism is the greatest enemy to man kind and needs to be destroyed entirely no reasonable Bolshevik thinks hmm yes this is my friend. The Soviets were not fucking stupid. The USSR tried to make a defensive alliance with literally everyone else against Germany and where the last to sign a pact with the Nazis. Partitioning Poland was a defensive move. Even my deeply conservative anti-communist European history professor admitted this. Please read actual scholarship that isn’t funded by the Hoover institute or similar organizations. People like Kotkin and Conquest are not reliable sources.
That’s a very convenient excuse and records are only as good as the people that keep them and the soviets were well known to doctor and forge documents and evidence.
You assume I haven’t read rather than I have but I simply disagree with you.
I’m aware no one wanted to help the soviets, no one had to but to say oh they joined the devil to lead the revolt from behind the front lines is absurd. You don’t get points for not being able to reign in your bullshit long enough for people to give a shit about you and yeah that applies just as well today as it did then.