Tell me more about you being ‘removed’ from humanity. I’d think that’s a neurodiverse thing to say but I’m keen on learning who else refers to oneself like that.
Probably. It took me many years and great effort to develop a sense of self and get in touch with / understand human emotions.
I always acknowledged I was physiologically human, but it felt like I was some other entity puppetting a fleshsuit in practice. It felt like I was playing a different game than everyone else. I had a crude theory of mind but didn’t see consciousness in others. People seemed impulsive with retroactive justification/attribution; incredibly “simple” and easy to manipulate; enigmatic clockwork but mostly predictable. Contradictions and lies were always very apparent to me. I was quite a violent little shit and liked to be left alone. Looking back, I’d hardly say I was sapient until around 9 years old, when it clicked that people had vivid feeling and dreams and complex inner-worlds, and I started to develop that too.
That accelerated with my first girlfriend who awakened that understanding. By age 12-13 was much less of a shithead, but I had a long way to go. I discovered emotion but it was faint and I didn’t understand it. Later around 16-17 I befriended a boy whom I’d have a deep unrequited love for, which continues to present day. His existence in my life let me explore things and develop myself further over the decade(s) to come.
I felt very out of place and time in a very literal sense; as if the world was meant to be one way, which was without my existence. I felt my influence on the world was a detriment to it. I wanted to minimize causing “waves” that would echo and alter things. Some felt insignificant and self-correcting. Others had broad ramifications that felt apparent to me, and that I’d go out of my way to avoid. I couldn’t help existing, but I could moderate the impact. I preferred to observe rather than act, as much as possibly. However, this may just be an explanation I came up with to fit my reclusive impulsives and social anxiety.
I had difficulty with my sense of self and even just saying “I” felt strange. It was easier to interact socially if I assumed a persona or acted a character.
My reactions to events were rarely spontaneous. I felt like I was given dialog options. Similarly with my thoughts. I would have many in parallel, from a plethora of different versions of “me”; from the most optimistic and wholesome to the most dejected and depraved imaginable. I would pick one or two and that would be “what I thought/felt.” Some media would depict characters “plagued by dark intrusive thoughts” and I always found that to be quaint and somewhat infant-like; comparing to my own experience of being under this spectral barrage that extended beyond the horizon in all dimensions, for every conceivable notion of light and dark… Perhaps from this explanation, you could understand how seeing other people having natural reactions and emotions would look very… simple. As if they had less agency.
My head was “noisy” to say the least, but I didn’t think in words; that only became the dominant mode of thought when I was about 28, after intentional effort. It felt rather limiting, but in some ways that is a good thing. I was able to spend a lot of time thinking about and understanding my cognition. Independently derived models involving desire-oriented micro-personalities etc. Which seemed to describe my experiences quite well; it felt like I was just operating at a lower level of the stack than most people. More typically subconscious processes were “above water” for me, which took energy to orchestrate.
Big overlap with autism, I’m sure. The most apparent being that I have sensory issues (low latent inhibition) and was prone to overstimulation; got easier to manage as I got older. I’ve never been diagnosed as autistic but I never engaged much with mental health services, so idk.
Also, I have difficulty learning abstract concepts; I really need a bounded but near-comprehensive / strongly internally linked model of understanding to really ‘get’ things enough to use them practically. (e.g. I couldn’t understand pointers in C until I understood assembly and built a mapping of concepts. C++ was a big stretch because it’s very high level and capable of great abstraction; you can write thousands of lines of C++ that don’t have any corresponding machine code. Took me a long time to differentiate the levels: one is programming the computer, one is programming the language; and both are vague means of expressing intent.)
Anyways, longer story somewhat long: I feel more human now than ever. Getting to this point took a lot of effort and time and surviving very dark and lonely places. Exploring myself and learning about feelings, understanding others, and learning to think and live life in a more human way. I’m still quite “other” in some respects, but I’ve accepted my existence in the world and experience authentic emotional reactions to things now. So that’s something.
I think I should elaborate a little bit more on emotion.
When I originally started feeling emotions, it was very faint and very controllable. It felt more like emulation. I wasn’t too sure if I was actually feeling emotions or just making it up.
Over time, they grew a little bit, especially with my first and second girlfriends. When my second girlfriend broke up with me, I felt sad and depressed because I just figured that’s what I should be feeling, so I did.
I likened emotions to radio stations. They were all present in the room, but I could feel whichever one I tuned into. I distinctly remember being driven by a lake in the passenger seat of a car, feeling depressed, and then I literally thought to myself: “well that’s enough of that; it’s starting to get boring.” And flipped my mood on a dime. Unironically “have you tried not being sad?”
But as time went on, and I played with emotions more and more, I grew more accustomed to them. They grew more natural and intense. When I met “him”, he was an anomaly to me in many ways; but one was the natural and impulsive of sparking of emotion. Feeling things uncued. That was when my “humanization” hit an inflection point; it started to become a goal for me, because I wanted to understand and feel more and be closer to him.
Edit: my childhood was a bit of a disaster, objectively speaking; so I’m sure there’s some trauma and coping bound up in all of this. But it never really bothered me, so it’s hard to claim causality. In fact, when people went out of their way to do good things for me or tried to care about my future, I felt like their efforts were wasted and it would be better spent on someone who needed it / would benefit from it; back to the “feeling like I shouldn’t be in the timeline” thing. I’d appreciate their efforts, like one would appreciate a child bringing a candy to a person in a coma: a wonderful gesture I could actively try to praise and acknowledge, but ultimately futile.
Well that guy is probably a space robot, brain in a jar, or a skinwalker or something, but that is the same sort of descriptor I would use for myself. Due to certain factors, some genetic, some circumstantial, I have always felt a distinct lack of connection with the rest of humanity. Not that unusual really. Someone in prison for a long time probably feel that the going ons of society are largely unrelated to them. A person who believes they are some transcendent intelligence temporarily residing in a human body might feel the same. People who can’t connect emotionally to others, etc.
If enough of these factors overlap it can make a person feel distinctly alien, despite recognizing that they have human physiology, are socialized/living in society, etc.
‘To walk among them, but not be of them’ is how I feel about people in general.
Ironic, as the branch is not separated from the tree, and won’t live long apart, yet knowing something is not the same as feeling it.
Tell me more about you being ‘removed’ from humanity. I’d think that’s a neurodiverse thing to say but I’m keen on learning who else refers to oneself like that.
(Okay, so I wrote a novel)
Probably. It took me many years and great effort to develop a sense of self and get in touch with / understand human emotions.
I always acknowledged I was physiologically human, but it felt like I was some other entity puppetting a fleshsuit in practice. It felt like I was playing a different game than everyone else. I had a crude theory of mind but didn’t see consciousness in others. People seemed impulsive with retroactive justification/attribution; incredibly “simple” and easy to manipulate; enigmatic clockwork but mostly predictable. Contradictions and lies were always very apparent to me. I was quite a violent little shit and liked to be left alone. Looking back, I’d hardly say I was sapient until around 9 years old, when it clicked that people had vivid feeling and dreams and complex inner-worlds, and I started to develop that too.
That accelerated with my first girlfriend who awakened that understanding. By age 12-13 was much less of a shithead, but I had a long way to go. I discovered emotion but it was faint and I didn’t understand it. Later around 16-17 I befriended a boy whom I’d have a deep unrequited love for, which continues to present day. His existence in my life let me explore things and develop myself further over the decade(s) to come.
I felt very out of place and time in a very literal sense; as if the world was meant to be one way, which was without my existence. I felt my influence on the world was a detriment to it. I wanted to minimize causing “waves” that would echo and alter things. Some felt insignificant and self-correcting. Others had broad ramifications that felt apparent to me, and that I’d go out of my way to avoid. I couldn’t help existing, but I could moderate the impact. I preferred to observe rather than act, as much as possibly. However, this may just be an explanation I came up with to fit my reclusive impulsives and social anxiety.
I had difficulty with my sense of self and even just saying “I” felt strange. It was easier to interact socially if I assumed a persona or acted a character.
My reactions to events were rarely spontaneous. I felt like I was given dialog options. Similarly with my thoughts. I would have many in parallel, from a plethora of different versions of “me”; from the most optimistic and wholesome to the most dejected and depraved imaginable. I would pick one or two and that would be “what I thought/felt.” Some media would depict characters “plagued by dark intrusive thoughts” and I always found that to be quaint and somewhat infant-like; comparing to my own experience of being under this spectral barrage that extended beyond the horizon in all dimensions, for every conceivable notion of light and dark… Perhaps from this explanation, you could understand how seeing other people having natural reactions and emotions would look very… simple. As if they had less agency.
My head was “noisy” to say the least, but I didn’t think in words; that only became the dominant mode of thought when I was about 28, after intentional effort. It felt rather limiting, but in some ways that is a good thing. I was able to spend a lot of time thinking about and understanding my cognition. Independently derived models involving desire-oriented micro-personalities etc. Which seemed to describe my experiences quite well; it felt like I was just operating at a lower level of the stack than most people. More typically subconscious processes were “above water” for me, which took energy to orchestrate.
Big overlap with autism, I’m sure. The most apparent being that I have sensory issues (low latent inhibition) and was prone to overstimulation; got easier to manage as I got older. I’ve never been diagnosed as autistic but I never engaged much with mental health services, so idk.
Also, I have difficulty learning abstract concepts; I really need a bounded but near-comprehensive / strongly internally linked model of understanding to really ‘get’ things enough to use them practically. (e.g. I couldn’t understand pointers in C until I understood assembly and built a mapping of concepts. C++ was a big stretch because it’s very high level and capable of great abstraction; you can write thousands of lines of C++ that don’t have any corresponding machine code. Took me a long time to differentiate the levels: one is programming the computer, one is programming the language; and both are vague means of expressing intent.)
Anyways, longer story somewhat long: I feel more human now than ever. Getting to this point took a lot of effort and time and surviving very dark and lonely places. Exploring myself and learning about feelings, understanding others, and learning to think and live life in a more human way. I’m still quite “other” in some respects, but I’ve accepted my existence in the world and experience authentic emotional reactions to things now. So that’s something.
I think I should elaborate a little bit more on emotion.
When I originally started feeling emotions, it was very faint and very controllable. It felt more like emulation. I wasn’t too sure if I was actually feeling emotions or just making it up.
Over time, they grew a little bit, especially with my first and second girlfriends. When my second girlfriend broke up with me, I felt sad and depressed because I just figured that’s what I should be feeling, so I did.
I likened emotions to radio stations. They were all present in the room, but I could feel whichever one I tuned into. I distinctly remember being driven by a lake in the passenger seat of a car, feeling depressed, and then I literally thought to myself: “well that’s enough of that; it’s starting to get boring.” And flipped my mood on a dime. Unironically “have you tried not being sad?”
But as time went on, and I played with emotions more and more, I grew more accustomed to them. They grew more natural and intense. When I met “him”, he was an anomaly to me in many ways; but one was the natural and impulsive of sparking of emotion. Feeling things uncued. That was when my “humanization” hit an inflection point; it started to become a goal for me, because I wanted to understand and feel more and be closer to him.
Edit: my childhood was a bit of a disaster, objectively speaking; so I’m sure there’s some trauma and coping bound up in all of this. But it never really bothered me, so it’s hard to claim causality. In fact, when people went out of their way to do good things for me or tried to care about my future, I felt like their efforts were wasted and it would be better spent on someone who needed it / would benefit from it; back to the “feeling like I shouldn’t be in the timeline” thing. I’d appreciate their efforts, like one would appreciate a child bringing a candy to a person in a coma: a wonderful gesture I could actively try to praise and acknowledge, but ultimately futile.
Well that guy is probably a space robot, brain in a jar, or a skinwalker or something, but that is the same sort of descriptor I would use for myself. Due to certain factors, some genetic, some circumstantial, I have always felt a distinct lack of connection with the rest of humanity. Not that unusual really. Someone in prison for a long time probably feel that the going ons of society are largely unrelated to them. A person who believes they are some transcendent intelligence temporarily residing in a human body might feel the same. People who can’t connect emotionally to others, etc. If enough of these factors overlap it can make a person feel distinctly alien, despite recognizing that they have human physiology, are socialized/living in society, etc.
‘To walk among them, but not be of them’ is how I feel about people in general.
Ironic, as the branch is not separated from the tree, and won’t live long apart, yet knowing something is not the same as feeling it.