I’ve only put in a few hours, but IMHO, Lucia has a better voice actor and is the more engaging character. Jason’s VA feels super flat to me. Especially when he’s juxtaposed to Cal, Brian, etc.
I get that he’s supposed to be an army vet that’s not super expressive, but Rockstar pulled this off better with Arthur in RDR2.
That’s said, I’m splitting hairs. The game is fucking great.
A rule of universe: The female VA is better, and it’s not even close.
I cite, as indisputable proof:
Femshep
Kassandra (AC Odyssey)
Female V (2077)
Identical dialogue, dramatically different. They killed it. Their performances held the games together, for me.
I know this isn’t the same thing (as they aren’t a choice in GTA VI, but rather a duo with unique lines), but still. It’s kinda my observation with “ensemble” casts too (like in the dialogue heavy, underrated Guardians of the Galaxy game).
Eh, that’s goes farther than what I meant. MaleShep was still good.
GotG Gamora is a good counterexample (even though that’s not a split character). She is intentionally emotionally “stunted” and angry compared to the extraverted, looser male cast, yet I remember feeling moved by her VA.
I’ve only put in a few hours, but IMHO, Lucia has a better voice actor and is the more engaging character. Jason’s VA feels super flat to me. Especially when he’s juxtaposed to Cal, Brian, etc.
I get that he’s supposed to be an army vet that’s not super expressive, but Rockstar pulled this off better with Arthur in RDR2.
That’s said, I’m splitting hairs. The game is fucking great.
A rule of universe: The female VA is better, and it’s not even close.
I cite, as indisputable proof:
Femshep
Kassandra (AC Odyssey)
Female V (2077)
Identical dialogue, dramatically different. They killed it. Their performances held the games together, for me.
I know this isn’t the same thing (as they aren’t a choice in GTA VI, but rather a duo with unique lines), but still. It’s kinda my observation with “ensemble” casts too (like in the dialogue heavy, underrated Guardians of the Galaxy game).
If it’s a male female split character there man is more likely to be generic emotionless angry action man.
Eh, that’s goes farther than what I meant. MaleShep was still good.
GotG Gamora is a good counterexample (even though that’s not a split character). She is intentionally emotionally “stunted” and angry compared to the extraverted, looser male cast, yet I remember feeling moved by her VA.