My earlier comment on why pre-release reviews are a useless metric: https://lemmy.world/post/54554541/26937476
I’m sure the user reviews will still be a solid 9/10 or higher,
I actually didn’t expect it to be that low, even if you account for user bombing type reviews, this is still not a 9/10.
Most of the complaints seem to be about Rockstar copying the mechanics and aspects of RDR2 into GTA, which clashes with the typical playstyle of GTA.
Top legitimate complaints are probably:
- The story and characters are lackluster
- The criminal profile system punishes you heavily for doing crime spree stuff
- Crime activities and the ability to choose want you want to do are limited, especially with regards to the story
- FPS drops even at a 30 FPS target and a handful of glitches
Anyway, I think it’ll probably adjust to maybe a 7/10 or 8/10 in a couple months or after the PC release, especially as more people play the game for themselves and put their own review up.


Fans who didn‘t buy the game because it was too expansive or simply not accessible deserve a vote too. Metacritic isn‘t a shop like Steam where you are able to purchase everything you see anyway.
I do not subscribe to the notion only buyers get to vote on something you are confronted with regardless of whether you own it or not. Especially when it‘s shoved into your face on every website right now. It pollutes every virtual space. It‘s inescapable.
I support the general idea of an outlet like Metacritic where anyone gets to give an opinion on something. However most of those have to be bots so it‘s a little pointless. It‘s 2026 and we can‘t have nice things after all.