This is a simplified version of our financial system where we are all fighting each other for the imaginary money needed because of interest…or am I wrong?
This is a simplified version of our financial system where we are all fighting each other for the imaginary money needed because of interest…or am I wrong?
Fractional reserve solves the problem of creating money , but it doesn’t solve the problem of paying it all back because of interest.
Interest is added to the money loaned out so there is never enough “out there” to pay it all back. Somoe has to lose (go bankrupt) eventually
Imagine someone paid the bank back another way, like, say Frank is a carpenter, and he offers to pay off his debt by, I dunno, fixing their door, whatever. The bank accepts.
Now, the physical dollar that they lent Frank and Frank then spent is out in the world, and there is no corresponding debt to pay back with it. Instead, 9 people owe $1.10, and it is possible to pay that all back.
Now, you’re right, if the Bank only accepts its own money as payment, its impossible to recover, but banks are basically always cool with barter, even modern ones, it just looks a little different. I have a mortgage on my house, for instance. At any time, I could tell my bank “actually, I’m not going to pay you any more money” and they would instead own my house. But the money I borrowed to pay the former owner, that money exists, still.
No financial system can truly live in a vacuum while it can be traded for goods and services, because debts don’t have to be repaid in money.
And now you understand why capitalism literally requires constant unending growth and expansion. You are correct, the only way for the debt to be repaid is if new money is added to the supply, and that can only happen if new loans are added, which only increases the amount of debt that needs to be repaid which can’t be repaid with the money in circulation at that exact moment, so the money supply needs to be expanded by more loans.
It’s a giant pyramid scheme
This is a simplistic representation of economics and capitalism. The economy requires constant growth, but, usually, so do people. The population grows, things get built and torn down, energy is harnessed to make and do things, and the wealth of the world keeps increasing. It doesn’t have to, but cities would be pretty cramped if we hadn’t created new housing since the world population was at 1 billion.
Our current economic system is predicated on constant growth, and that can certainly cause problems, whether it be due to epidemics, recessions, or the likely stabilizing of the world population.
I think that’s a very positive spin on financialization that ignores all the evidence to the contrary. Yes, we need to build more housing and more productive forces. But the reality is that in the US economy, at least a third of the economy is either non-productive, actively destructive, self-dealing, made up entirely, or rent seeking:
These categories account for roughly 29.5% to 32.5% of U.S. GDP on a direct basis, or approximately 38% to 41% of U.S. GDP when the rent-seeking and transactional portions of real estate are included.
And that doesn’t include soda, cigarettes, and alcohol, which is almost 2% of GDP, nor does it include predatory lending/payday loans, gambling, paying farmers not to farm, and other bullshit. All in its likely that a full 40% of the economy, possibly more, doesn’t resemble anything like housing, factories, medicine, food, clothing, community, arts, etc.
At a glance I’d say about half those points have nothing to do with capitalism and predate it and a noticeable chunk have to do with politics and society, which will still exist if we didn’t have capitalism or our current economy, and again predate capitalism and our economy. While they might be problems or taking more money than you think they should, that doesn’t make them inherent problems with the economy per se.
You missed the point. You said my characterization of capitalism being in an inexorable inflation mostly driven by debt was not being fair to the fact that the economy has to constantly expand because humanity is growing and needs more. The point of my list was that at least a third if not nearly half of the US economy specifically has nothing to do with that need but is instead non-productive, destructive, deleterious, or exists primarily for the sake of moving money without any social benefit.