This is a simplified version of our financial system where we are all fighting each other for the imaginary money needed because of interest…or am I wrong?
Farmer uses 10 bags of wheat as seeds and at the end of the season, farmer harvest 100 bags.
But since he borrowed the first 10 bags at 10% interest, farmer now owes 11 bags. Farmer is now left with only 89 bags without any theoretical problems.
Money is somewhat similar, based on production, but fucking more complicated.The system we have is much dumber than that.
You are a bank. You have $10. You have ten rich/corporate friends,
each with a piece of paper saying they have $1 of value in the market. They use that as collateral to get a $100 loan from you. You get a loan from the federal bank for $1000 using your $10 as collateral, then give your buds the $100 they each want with that $1 collateral.They use some of that $100 to make the company worth more and buy more stock, they now have $2 of stock. They use $5 of that hundred to pay you interest. You use $2 of each of their dollars to pay the federal bank interest. You make $30 dollars profit out of nothing.
They then put up another $1 each. You get another $1000 loan, using $10 from the interest you got as collateral.
Repeat as long as the company value goes up. (Note that as soon as it has a major correction, you as the bank or the fed may call in those loans and the friends are fucked.)
Until then, the friends now have $190 each from a initial purchase of $1 of a company’s value. To the tax man, they are 188 dollars in debt, so they don’t pay any taxes.
What mike_wooskey said: fractional reserve banking. You’re not wrong, just missing a lot of detail that makes it make sense.
Another somewhat related aspect of money is that it doesn’t need to be hard currency to be useful; money is in effect just a token of I-owe-you, and this can take any form as long as there’s enough trust that the lender will get their value back.
That’s how banks can do this: they have enough collateral or enforcement mechanisms in place to ensure they will get their money back, and as such they can loan out more money than they actually have. Most of the time this works fine, and helps stimulate the economic system as a whole, as it is beneficial for everyone involved for money to move around.
For an example of when something like this goes wrong, see 2008; Banks folded after it turned out they had given out loans that could not be covered if unpaid.
Fractional reserve solves the problem of creating money , but it doesn’t solve the problem of paying it all back because of interest.
Interest is added to the money loaned out so there is never enough “out there” to pay it all back. Somoe has to lose (go bankrupt) eventually
Imagine someone paid the bank back another way, like, say Frank is a carpenter, and he offers to pay off his debt by, I dunno, fixing their door, whatever. The bank accepts.
Now, the physical dollar that they lent Frank and Frank then spent is out in the world, and there is no corresponding debt to pay back with it. Instead, 9 people owe $1.10, and it is possible to pay that all back.
Now, you’re right, if the Bank only accepts its own money as payment, its impossible to recover, but banks are basically always cool with barter, even modern ones, it just looks a little different. I have a mortgage on my house, for instance. At any time, I could tell my bank “actually, I’m not going to pay you any more money” and they would instead own my house. But the money I borrowed to pay the former owner, that money exists, still.
No financial system can truly live in a vacuum while it can be traded for goods and services, because debts don’t have to be repaid in money.
And now you understand why capitalism literally requires constant unending growth and expansion. You are correct, the only way for the debt to be repaid is if new money is added to the supply, and that can only happen if new loans are added, which only increases the amount of debt that needs to be repaid which can’t be repaid with the money in circulation at that exact moment, so the money supply needs to be expanded by more loans.
It’s a giant pyramid scheme
This is a simplistic representation of economics and capitalism. The economy requires constant growth, but, usually, so do people. The population grows, things get built and torn down, energy is harnessed to make and do things, and the wealth of the world keeps increasing. It doesn’t have to, but cities would be pretty cramped if we hadn’t created new housing since the world population was at 1 billion.
Our current economic system is predicated on constant growth, and that can certainly cause problems, whether it be due to epidemics, recessions, or the likely stabilizing of the world population.
I think that’s a very positive spin on financialization that ignores all the evidence to the contrary. Yes, we need to build more housing and more productive forces. But the reality is that in the US economy, at least a third of the economy is either non-productive, actively destructive, self-dealing, made up entirely, or rent seeking:
- Financial services and insurance
- Intellectual property, DRM, and anti-piracy protection
- National defense and military
- Police, courts, and prisons
- Advertising and public relations
- Legal services
- Healthcare billing and insurance administration
- Tax preparation and accounting compliance
- Payment processing and credit card fees
- Private security and surveillance
- Regulatory compliance and corporate HR bureaucracy
- Lobbying and political campaigns
- Management consulting and corporate M&A
- Credentialism and test preparation
- Real estate economic rent, brokerage commissions, and speculative leasing (excluding actual property maintenance, construction, and physical housing upkeep)
These categories account for roughly 29.5% to 32.5% of U.S. GDP on a direct basis, or approximately 38% to 41% of U.S. GDP when the rent-seeking and transactional portions of real estate are included.
And that doesn’t include soda, cigarettes, and alcohol, which is almost 2% of GDP, nor does it include predatory lending/payday loans, gambling, paying farmers not to farm, and other bullshit. All in its likely that a full 40% of the economy, possibly more, doesn’t resemble anything like housing, factories, medicine, food, clothing, community, arts, etc.
At a glance I’d say about half those points have nothing to do with capitalism and predate it and a noticeable chunk have to do with politics and society, which will still exist if we didn’t have capitalism or our current economy, and again predate capitalism and our economy. While they might be problems or taking more money than you think they should, that doesn’t make them inherent problems with the economy per se.
You missed the point. You said my characterization of capitalism being in an inexorable inflation mostly driven by debt was not being fair to the fact that the economy has to constantly expand because humanity is growing and needs more. The point of my list was that at least a third if not nearly half of the US economy specifically has nothing to do with that need but is instead non-productive, destructive, deleterious, or exists primarily for the sake of moving money without any social benefit.
"If you had a financial system with $10" you’d have a fixed money supply. Actual banks that loan money dont exist in this kind of system, they exist in systems where new money can be issued by governments or “central” banks.
Back in the day, as new gold was mined, governments would purchase it (with printed money or other IOUs). Now, a “central” bank has the authority to increase money supply by issuing new money directly (by “loaning” it to other banks, that can then loan it out).
Bold of you to write that.
The financial system alone doesn’t make sense without means of production. Typically your baker will take on a loan to build an oven. With that, he can make more money faster, and with the increased productivity he can pay back the loan and keep more for himself, meaning spend it on other avenues. Such a system works best if other means of production are built out at the same pace, and if loans are indeed primarily used to create more efficient means of production.
It stops working if the increased “productivity” are just numbers on paper without actual growth in the means of production.
And this creates a bit of a conundrum when physical growth isn’t possible anymore, maybe due to exhausted resources.
I don’t think you’re wrong. I think that’s the nature of both fiat currencies and fractional reserve banking.
Lots of good explanations in here, basically money is made up to symbolize the worth of something. In your version, you skip over the fact that the interest is just a numeric agreement of the value and cost of that borrowing over time. In the digital world that agreement could be wiped, and now there’s no interest or deal evidence of you owing anything. But with that goes the value, and maybe even the record of you having any of it. Unless it’s turned into something tangible, it’s all pretend, but we all agree on the pretending so we can use it.
Bartering could have interest in it, where you agree on the how the value of two actual things relate, and agree to give something back to the person later at an inflated value (one more sheep) to pay for the service of borrowing one of their horses for a bit.
They will have to create that value in the form of goods or services. Otherwise, if no one is providing any goods or services, there will always be only $10 in their economy.
It’s not coming from anywhere, it’s expected to not exist.
Money has problems: Paper based money can get actually destroyed. You can lose coins. The value of the currency will slowly go up over time, because there is less actual physical money to go around. That’s silly, we can just make more.
The way we make more, is credit. Credit is given out when someone has an idea and wants to do something. But that idea is risky. If 10 people say they want to start a business and pay back 110% in 10 years, chances are, not all 10 will make it. Nobody can’t predict who will fail. The credit a bank gives out, will not always come back. It is expected that some won’t. The business of the bank is to stay positive, get more credit money back than they loan.
There is another aspect where valuations change. If you buy company stock and the stock falls, that value is gone, erased.
The financial system and the monetary system are built in a way that is “fuzzy” and not precise in a way that allows the system to deal with the real world.
You might have simplified things down too far.
Imagine a universe with only two kgs of matter. How would life form?
That extra $1 comes from some other poor sucker that borrowed money. Money is fake, ultimately. This is why it is unsustainable and why there is always inflation. The trick is they don’t care. The engine itself is mostly stable. We’re trapped in it. And we’re cogs in it.
If all the $10 is held by the bank, why would anyone want to borrow it? Everyone is getting by without any money, probably by bartering. So the money has no use or value.
The way it really works is closer to this:
To give the money value, the government needs to make a rule that taxes need to be paid in… Mony, let’s say. Then to make sure people have Mony to pay their taxes with, the government needs to create the Mony for them to use. The government creates Mony at a certain rate each year, gives it to the bank to lend out, then people use the Mony for stuff, eventually paying their taxes. The tax Mony is then removed from the economy and destroyed. The two rates at which the government creates and destroys Mony is what controls inflation.Of course that’s not the common or popular concept of how it works. It’s just the correct one. If you want more details, look into Modern Monetary Theory or MMT.
You can get your $10, make a purchase with that $1 to put it back into circulation, and then get the remaining dollar. In the end, you have $10 and $1 worth of goods.





