At some point, I ran across an argument along the lines of: “We hunger, and food exists. We thirst, and water exists. We feel horny, and sex is real. We yearn for God, and so I conclude that God exists.”

Now, I can easily pick this apart a bunch of different ways, the easiest one being that just because you want some to exist doesn’t mean that it really exists. But what I’m really hoping for is a couple of counterexamples: something like “Yes, well, we all want a unicorn, too, but unicorns don’t exist.”

This particular one doesn’t work because wanting a unicorn isn’t a universal desire the way food or sex are (even counting asexual people, we can still say that the vast majority of people want sex). But maybe some of you can think of something.

  • @Gradually_Adjusting
    link
    English
    81 year ago

    It warrants little more than dismissiveness. “I yearn for quiet, yet here you are.”

    • @arensbOP
      link
      English
      21 year ago

      I admire the quippiness, but in this case, I heard the argument from Justin Brierley, explaining why, after ten years of hosting a podcast where believers (usually Christians) and unbelievers regularly engage in debate, he’s still a Christian. I actually enjoyed his show, and he seems like a nice guy, so I wouldn’t want to want to tell him to piss off.

      But I did roll my eyes when I heard this particular argument. It’s just evidence that smart people can believe very silly things, especially when it comes to religion.

      • @Gradually_Adjusting
        link
        English
        11 year ago

        That’s good then. Don’t be snide to anyone who doesn’t have it coming.

        I might be smart, and I definitely have dealt with a few stupid beliefs in my time. We’re none of us perfect