Yup, boarder towns in red states are going to start stopping women as they travel through their towns to make sure they aren’t pregnant.

  • Flying Squid
    link
    121 year ago

    Bank robbers do not get charged with driving to the bank.

    • @Kittenstix
      link
      111 year ago

      Better comparison is

      Weed smokers don’t get charged for driving across state lines to buy and smoke pot in a legal state.

      • Flying Squid
        link
        61 year ago

        You don’t think prosecutors add charges when someone commits a crime? Why do you think Trump is being charged with multiple things?

        I have never heard of the charge of ‘driving to a crime’ being added.

        But feel free to show that driving to a bank robbery is a federal crime. I would like to see that law please.

        • @Riccosuave
          link
          21 year ago

          I think what the previous poster was attempting to say is that crossing state lines in the commission of a crime can get you charged with additional crimes. That was the similarity to this specific example in relation to traveling for an abortion or reproductive health care. I just don’t think the bank robbery example was very good.

          • @Kittenstix
            link
            4
            edit-2
            1 year ago

            Ok but the better analog here is driving across state lines to smoke weed, you can’t stop someone from doing that, even though it is a crime in the state you live in.

            and that is a federal crime, but you still won’t get charged for it.

            • @Riccosuave
              link
              21 year ago

              First, let me say that I agree this is a much better example.

              One caveat would be purchasing Cannabis in a state where it is legal, and then transporting the Cannabis back into a state where it is illegal. That could subject a person who made a legal purchase to criminal charges.

              That same logic could be used to justify charging a person for seeking an abortion or reproductive health care in a state where it is legal, and then returning to a state where it is illegal.

              Again, I am not justifying this whatsoever. I think this is heinous, unethical, and clearly a violation of civil liberties among other things. However, playing devil’s advocate here by pointing out some of the sticky argumentation around the edges that can and will be deployed to allow for this kind of post-hoc justification for criminal charges.