• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    1
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    If you try to ban breeds you just get an ever-expanding list of banned breeds, and penalise good owners alongside bad. People who want dogs as a weapon, or who want the look but can’t put the time in, will always find new breeds to abuse.

    Leash-laws, compulsory muzzling, licencing for larger dogs, and training for owners are much more effective. This problem is exploding (again) because so many inexperienced people got dogs during the pandemic and now don’t have the time to spend with them.

    The problem isn’t going to disappear just because you can name a new hate-breed of the month. All doggoes are good doggoes, too many owners let them down. We can do something about that, if we want to.

    Reposting this from above (not my link originally): Why Breed-Specific Legislation Doesn’t Work

    • Blake [he/him]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      11 year ago

      If you try to ban breeds you just get an ever-expanding list of banned breeds

      Yes, that is how a banned breeds list works, and pretty much all laws. “Oh but you’ll have to ban other breeds in the future!”, great! We’re not trying to write the One Law that is forever good and valid. That’s like saying, “if you ban certain activities you’ll get an ever-expanding list of crimes!”

      penalise good owners alongside bad

      No one has to have their beloved pet put down. The banned breeds list only “harms” breeders, and breeders are so fucking unethical and bad for dog’s welfare that I couldn’t really give a solitary fuck.

      People who want dogs as a weapon will always find new breeds to abuse.

      Right, but we don’t say “there’s no point in banning guns because knives still exist”, do we? We can have both sensible measures to prevent cruel owners AND restricted dangerous dog breeds can’t we?

      All doggoes are good doggoes

      That’s just not true, sadly. From what we know about dog breeding is that aggression is a very heritable trait, so dogs that have been bred for fighting, even with good upbringing, are inherently more likely to snap and harm someone than a dog in the same situation which was bred from less aggressive dogs.

      We can do something about that, if we want to.

      Yes, we can - stop breeding them. Stop selling them. Stop treating them like slaves.