• @DarthBueller
    link
    4
    edit-2
    9 months ago

    Is there a middle ground between individualism and communitarianism? I am looking for perspectives in earnest (i.e., this isn’t a “gotcha” question). I agree that “rugged individualism” ends up trampling people.

    • @dustyData
      link
      English
      11
      edit-2
      9 months ago

      Social democracy, maybe. At least they acknowledge social justice as a core political value. Plenty of socialism political stances are emphatic about social justice without going full on accelerationist authoritarian communism.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      29 months ago

      Basing the collective mentality and the legal framework upon ubiquitous and mutual sovereignty. That is, an individual is sovereign, an organization is sovereign, etc - and thus, none have rights over another, except as agreed to by ongoing mutual agreement. Anyone can withdraw, and no other has the right to deny that. Disputes are resolved through finding the path of least incursion.

      Implicit in this is the notion of ‘innocent until proven guilty’, that abortion is a right, that forcing medical choices (including vaccination) has no moral standing, that one can arm oneself, and one can also, by contract, participate in a community which disarms itself. Government bodies are ultimately services, in this model, which people, at some point, contractually agree to - or don’t.

      The right to withdraw is a necessary one, as any contract one cannot deny or reject when one wants to is, at its root, compulsion or slavery.

    • @givesomefucks
      link
      English
      19 months ago

      Is there a middle ground between individualism and communitarianism

      Socialism…

      The middle ground between capitalism and communism is socialism.

      Everyone gets enough, and if you work hard you get more.

      The Overton window has just shifted so far right that “middle ground” has started being treated as extreme.