Both Republicans likely need the support of Democrats to prevail in their battle over the speakership. Here’s how that could shake out.

  • Ertebolle
    link
    fedilink
    361 year ago

    The other side of the argument is that McCarthy is the GOP’s greatest fundraiser, and getting rid of him would help Democrats take back the House. No replacement for McCarthy would have the same set of relationships and the donor network and political operation.

    This is, to me, the winning argument - it hurts them politically, both by taking away their best fundraiser and by replacing him with somebody who’s likely to be even more extreme and so do even more dumb things the Democrats can campaign against. A McCarthy replacement is even likely to shut down the government in 45 days than McCarthy is, and for Democrats that’s probably a good thing - Republicans screwing up air travel right before Thanksgiving and taking away government employees’ paychecks right before Christmas.

    Is it good for the country, maybe not, but Republicans losing the House in 2024 will do several orders of magnitude more good for the country than whatever harm might be done by that short-term idiocy.

    • @Cryophilia
      link
      91 year ago

      Historically, when Republicans have shut down the government under a Democratic president, the Democrats get an outsized share of blame. If I were the Dems, I would avoid a shutdown if possible, even just for purely political reasons

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        51 year ago

        As the republicans have veeered more and more into extremism, the veneer has been lifted and they get most of the blame. Their propaganda machine doesn’t work as well when people know it’s propaganda. Obviously the third that live in an alternative reality still blame the dems.

        • @Cryophilia
          link
          51 year ago

          I think that’s more a reflection of your specific changing tastes in media/social networks, and not people in general.

      • bobalot
        link
        11 year ago

        Didn’t work in 2020.

        Democrats overperformed.

        • @Cryophilia
          link
          11 year ago

          True. Maybe the electorate is getting wise.

          • bobalot
            link
            11 year ago

            Roe vs. Wade was overturned.