I just recently started documenting my code as it helped me. Though I feel like my documentations are a bit too verbose and probably unneeded on obvious parts of my code.

So I started commenting above a few lines of code and explain it in a short sentence what I do or why I do that, then leave a space under it for the next line so it is easier to read.

What do you think about this?

Edit: real code example from one of my projects:

async def discord_login_callback(request: HttpRequest) -> HttpResponseRedirect:
    async def exchange_oauth2_code(code: str) -> str | None:
        data = {
            'grant_type': 'authorization_code',
            'code': code,
            'redirect_uri': OAUTH2_REDIRECT_URI
        }
        headers = {
            'Content-Type': 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded'
        }
        async with httpx.AsyncClient() as client:
            # get user's access and refresh tokens
            response = await client.post(f"{BASE_API_URI}/oauth2/token", data=data, headers=headers, auth=(CLIENT_ID, CLIENT_SECRET))
            if response.status_code == 200:
                access_token, refresh_token = response.json()["access_token"], response.json()["refresh_token"]

                # get user data via discord's api
                user_data = await client.get(f"{BASE_API_URI}/users/@me", headers={"Authorization": f"Bearer {access_token}"})
                user_data = user_data.json()
                user_data.update({"access_token": access_token, "refresh_token": refresh_token}) # add tokens to user_data

                return user_data, None
            else:
                # if any error occurs, return error context
                context = generate_error_dictionary("An error occurred while trying to get user's access and refresh tokens", f"Response Status: {response.status_code}\nError: {response.content}")
                return None, context

    code = request.GET.get("code")
    user, context = await exchange_oauth2_code(code)

    # login if user's discord user data is returned
    if user:
        discord_user = await aauthenticate(request, user=user)
        await alogin(request, user=discord_user, backend="index.auth.DiscordAuthenticationBackend")
        return redirect("index")
    else:
        return render(request, "index/errorPage.html", context)
  • @CookieOfFortune
    link
    -36 months ago

    To my knowledge that just formats existing comments. With LLMs you could probably do 95% of the actual commenting.

    • Superb
      link
      fedilink
      English
      106 months ago

      Useful comments should provide context or information not already available in the code. There is no LLM that can generate good comments from the source alone

      • silas
        link
        fedilink
        English
        3
        edit-2
        6 months ago

        Codium does surprisingly well at generating JSDoc, and it processes your code within the context of your entire codebase. Still not quite there yet, but you might be surprised

      • @CookieOfFortune
        link
        16 months ago

        Why wouldn’t it be able to? It can link similar code structure to data in its training set. Maybe the ones that aren’t at that level but it’s hardly a stretch to make these inferences. Most of the code you write is hardly novel.

        • Superb
          link
          fedilink
          English
          66 months ago

          If it’s not exactly novel, how many comments do you really need?

          An LLM is just gonna describe the code it sees. Good comments should include information and context that is not already in the source.

          • @CookieOfFortune
            link
            16 months ago

            I’m mostly talking about when you need to use JSDoc format which are usually for interfaces, so it’s usually just a chore for humans.

            Probably harder to get good comments inside code, but it might still be possible.