• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    71 year ago

    People always say this and then fail to provide a single example of when proper socialism existed and then destroyed the country.

    • diprount_tomato
      link
      -4
      edit-2
      1 year ago

      “This theory when applied didn’t end like in the book, therefore it’s not really that theory”

      • @LemmysMum
        link
        41 year ago

        Communism without actually sharing isn’t communism. Democracy without fair elections isn’t democracy. Socialism without the socialisation of the benefit of production is not socialism. Your ignorance of these things doesn’t change what they are.

        • diprount_tomato
          link
          -4
          edit-2
          11 months ago

          Again, the “the theory when applied doesn’t look like in the book so it’s not real communism”

          • @LemmysMum
            link
            3
            edit-2
            11 months ago

            No. The theory when applied doesn’t follow the book. The difference is something called contextual nuance, and you have no grasp of it.

            Your position is like North Korea claiming democracy doesn’t work because they say they are one and it’s not working.

            • diprount_tomato
              link
              -211 months ago

              The theory when applied ends up not following the book… I wonder why?

              • @LemmysMum
                link
                3
                edit-2
                11 months ago

                The theory when applied ends up not following the book… I wonder why?

                Because you can’t read, as proven.

                The difference is something called contextual nuance, and you have no grasp of it.

                Your position is like North Korea claiming democracy doesn’t work because they say they are one and it’s not working.

                You can continue acting stupid, but in your case I’m not sure it’s an act.

                • diprount_tomato
                  link
                  -2
                  edit-2
                  11 months ago

                  North Korea’s definitely working. If it didn’t work it would have collapsed. It’s still hell, but a working one

                  • @LemmysMum
                    link
                    4
                    edit-2
                    11 months ago

                    Is the Democratic Republic Of North Korea a Democracy? Because you’re trying to say yes.

                    Like I said, it’s called contextual nuance and you have no grasp of it.

                    You can continue acting stupid, but in your case I’m not sure it’s an act.

            • diprount_tomato
              link
              -311 months ago

              No, it’s not a democracy because it doesn’t even bother following actual democratic principles. It’s just like Napoleon’s idea of democracy: I am the people, therefore if I have absolute power I’m being democratic.

              Basically Cuba on steroids

              I copy-pasted my answer because you copy-pasted your comment

              • @LemmysMum
                link
                3
                edit-2
                11 months ago

                The only thing like Napoleon’s around here is your ego. Shame you don’t have the brains to go with it.

                • diprount_tomato
                  link
                  -311 months ago

                  Love your response, totally not an ad hominem

                  • @LemmysMum
                    link
                    3
                    edit-2
                    11 months ago

                    Of course it’s an ad hominem dumbass, I was insulting your lack of intelligence because I’ve already destroyed your argument but you’re literally too fucking stupid to clue on.

                    If you want to keep being clowned on like a child, keep being as ignorant as one. Running circles around you as you try to keep up is great practice. They say you shouldn’t argue with idiots like yourself, but that’s a skill issue imo.

                    I don’t expect your inevitable reply to miraculously be tempered with newfound cognizance either. I expect you to continue to act within your very restrictive personal limitations.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            2
            edit-2
            11 months ago

            North Korea calls itself democratic. Everyone in the country votes for a new leader every five years. It’s just that there’s only one name on the ballot.

            One would be foolhardy to call that democracy.

            One would be even more foolhardy to argue that this means that democracy is a stupid idea.

            Likewise with socialism.