it’s cute you think i haven’t. i have some real problems with poore-nemecek 2018, and i will flat-out dismiss any paper based on it. i was recently linked to one that came out same year but whose author i cannot remember that dealt with LCAs that also had terrible methodology. if those two papers are representative at all of the state of the current research into agricultural ecology, the field is a fucking disgrace to the academy. and, unfortunately, many of the papers that have come out in the last 5 years are based on poore-nemecek, and should be rigorously evaluated.
but since you seem like you have read some papers on the subject, do you have any to suggest?
the owid links are heavily dependent on poore-nemecek and i’m not going to bother trying to separate the wheat from the chaff there. i don’t know if i’ve seen cassidy2013 or Erb 2016, but i will certainly be digging into them and their methodology. i am very concerned about the fact that poore-nemecek shows up in the references for Eisen 2022. if you’ve read these can you explain the methodology? if not, can i task you with actually reading eisen et al (and its references) so you can explain its methodology while i read the other two?
Oh no this would be a waste of your time I’m afraid I’m not a researcher in this field but follow the work of some. Unfortunately they are not active around here so I can’t even tag them.
You seems pretty articulate tho. Can I ask for your credentials?
it’s cute you think i haven’t. i have some real problems with poore-nemecek 2018, and i will flat-out dismiss any paper based on it. i was recently linked to one that came out same year but whose author i cannot remember that dealt with LCAs that also had terrible methodology. if those two papers are representative at all of the state of the current research into agricultural ecology, the field is a fucking disgrace to the academy. and, unfortunately, many of the papers that have come out in the last 5 years are based on poore-nemecek, and should be rigorously evaluated.
but since you seem like you have read some papers on the subject, do you have any to suggest?
edit:
minor typo AND i looked up the paper: Heller, MC (2018)
I am cute and hope that you feel so too.
https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/8/3/034015
https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms11382?origin=ppub
https://ourworldindata.org/environmental-impacts-of-food
https://journals.plos.org/climate/article?id=10.1371/journal.pclm.0000010
https://ourworldindata.org/food-choice-vs-eating-local
IPCC reports are on their website.
the owid links are heavily dependent on poore-nemecek and i’m not going to bother trying to separate the wheat from the chaff there. i don’t know if i’ve seen cassidy2013 or Erb 2016, but i will certainly be digging into them and their methodology. i am very concerned about the fact that poore-nemecek shows up in the references for Eisen 2022. if you’ve read these can you explain the methodology? if not, can i task you with actually reading eisen et al (and its references) so you can explain its methodology while i read the other two?
Oh no this would be a waste of your time I’m afraid I’m not a researcher in this field but follow the work of some. Unfortunately they are not active around here so I can’t even tag them.
You seems pretty articulate tho. Can I ask for your credentials?