HERSHEY, Pa. (CBS) – A Florida woman is upset about the lack of designs on Reese’s holiday-themed peanut butter candy - and now she’s taking parent company Hershey to court over it.

Cynthia Kelly filed a federal class-action lawsuit Thursday in the U.S. District Court in the Middle District of Florida, alleging several Reese’s products don’t match their photos as depicted on the wrappers.

For example, Reese’s peanut butter pumpkins are merely pumpkin-shaped hunks of peanut-butter-stuffed chocolate, and the actual product has no Jack O’lantern-style carvings as the wrapper depicts, Kelly alleges.

  • Rosco
    link
    fedilink
    3211 months ago

    I would sue Hershey’s for selling vomit chocolate, this stuff is shockingly bad.

    • @PlantJam
      link
      1111 months ago

      The miniature peanut butter cups from trader Joe’s, however, are perfect.

      • Blackout
        link
        fedilink
        1311 months ago

        When they came out they had both milk and dark chocolate variations. Its nice to see the dark side win one.

    • @Tangent5280
      link
      411 months ago

      That has something to do with the way that milk and chocolate is processed - in some markets they still have their delicious original taste. But its a agamble though, and nothing ruins my day as much as biting down on a much awaited hersheys kiss after a long day and almost-barfing

      • @JustAManOnAToilet
        link
        3111 months ago

        It’s the addition of butyric acid during production to lengthen shelf life.

      • insomniac_lemon
        link
        fedilink
        211 months ago

        That has something to do with the way that milk and chocolate is processed

        I’m pretty sure it’s just that it’s mostly sugar (low cocoa %). At least the higher % stuff (like special dark) tastes much better to me. With holiday versions it might have more chocolate than the basic cups (or maybe even just lower cocoa % particularly for easter).

        In other countries they have actual standards for cocoa %.

        • @JustAManOnAToilet
          link
          2211 months ago

          Butyric acid is a compound found in milk products and is also present in rancid butter and vomit, which is why it might evoke a “sick” taste association. Some American chocolate manufacturers add butyric acid during production to give the chocolate a longer shelf life.

          • @Tangent5280
            link
            811 months ago

            It’s a self serving idea, because they know that chocolate with butyric acid added in is going to be sitting on the shelves a loooong time.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          -411 months ago

          Interesting little factoid I learned after we got dogs. While still not good for them, most American chocolate like Hershey’s is not as toxic as most people think it is for dogs.

          This is because of the low cacao content, it’s a lot of fat and sugar but not a lot of cacao which is really toxic part of chocolate for dogs.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              111 months ago

              No, but the sugar is not good for dogs either.

              The United States requires a lesser percentage cacao in their chocolates, ten percent to be exact, while in Europe anything considered “chocolate” is twenty percent or higher. Less cacao means less theobromine (and caffeine) which is the chemical in chocolate toxic to dogs.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      -111 months ago

      This. When I went to the USA I tried one of those, as through media I had the idea that it was the best chocolate America had.

      I took one but and then threw the rest in the trash where it belongs. Absolutely filthy stuff.

      • @RampantParanoia2365
        link
        1411 months ago

        I’m really curious what media could have possibly led you to that conclusion.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          111 months ago

          Hershey’s features a lot in American tv and movies and as such is a known brand that was not available over here. That way you get curious.

          • @afraid_of_zombies
            link
            311 months ago

            Ubiquitous does not “best”, very often it is not the case.

      • Kata1yst
        link
        fedilink
        411 months ago

        Yuck. No, it’s certainly not our best. It’s the bargain bin stuff that manages to push the most volume and marketing. You see it a lot around the holidays, but not too much besides.

        Ghirardelli might be our best of the large brands, though it’s now owned by Lindt.

        We of course have a ton of smaller brands with higher quality too.

        • @Furedadmins
          link
          211 months ago

          Any of the mars chocolates are streets beyond any of the spoiled milk Hershey’s even.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          111 months ago

          Lindt makes basic-ass chocolate for premium prices, I’m quite sure you have better chocolate producers but as everywhere else they’re quite low-volume and you won’t find them in supermarkets. Also be prepared to pay up to 10 bucks per 50g, but it’ll be worth it – like once every couple of years, as a gift, etc.

          If you have an Aldi close by try Moser-Roth, they’re approximately Lindt quality at prices actually reflecting the quality of cocoa in it.