I saw this post and wanted to ask the opposite. What are some items that really aren’t worth paying the expensive version for? Preferably more extreme or unexpected examples.

  • guyrocket
    link
    fedilink
    10911 months ago

    I buy a lot of generic or store brand stuff. Usually I’m comfortable doing this with things that have been around for a long time like bleach, laundry soap, and basic foods. I assume that it is not difficult to do these things so anyone can make it and there’s little if any difference between brands.

    On this topic: I heard once that you should first buy cheap tools. Use them until they break and then decide what you want to improve about those tools and buy better ones. Often those first tools never break. This seems like pretty good advice for most things.

    • snooggums
      link
      fedilink
      6911 months ago

      The tools is good advice most of the time, but not if the tool would fail dangerously. Don’t skimp on car jacks, table saws, or other things that are likely to injure you if they fail.

      Screwdrivers/drills/hammers/crowbars/etc. don’t need to be expensive if you are going to use them rarely as the professional grade is mostly about being used all day every day and being able to survive rough handling by tired workers.

    • @zigmus64
      link
      2211 months ago

      Harbor Freight is fucking awesome.

      • @cmbabul
        link
        1211 months ago

        Milwaukee is awesome, but Harbor Freight is more than good enough for the needs of 95% of people

    • @SlopppyEngineer
      link
      1611 months ago

      Sometimes, the store brand is exactly the same stuff from the same factory. They literally stop production from a famous brand, change packaging to a store brand and resume producing the same stuff in a different package. The price difference is mostly marketing and that can be a huge part of the budget.

      For some other store brands, they do use cheaper ingredients. However, after the inflation we had, many fancy brands also started doing this to keep profits up so a famous brand is no guarantee for a great product.

      And some brands just sell the same stuff but add some additional perfumes and whatnot to justify the cost. They give me a rash so I’d rather get the cheap ones.

    • @Potatos_are_not_friends
      link
      1511 months ago

      On this topic: I heard once that you should first buy cheap tools. Use them until they break and then decide what you want to improve about those tools and buy better ones. Often those first tools never break. This seems like pretty good advice for most things.

      As a person who has been buying cheap tools all my life… YES! Most of the tools I bought came from thrift stores and the bargain bin. If someone stole my toolset, it’ll probably amount to $60 lost.

      But they’ve lasted for 15 years now. Not because of quality. But because my frequency of usage is so low. I’ve used a hammer what… 20 times in my life?

      I did replace my screwdriver kit and Allen wrench set twice, because I use them a lot.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        411 months ago

        I’ve used hammers a lot in my life. I came across a really cheap brand of hammer which made me realize it was in fact possible to make a hammer poorly. The head wasn’t even hardened. Hitting nails literally left dents in it. I broke the claw trying to pull a nail that was less than 6" long. It’s possible that someone in your situation would have found value in this hammer, but I think someone who did something more involved than framing a single wall wouldn’t.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          211 months ago

          As someone who got hit in the face with the head of a hammer that flew off the handle, I don’t roll with cheap hammers. Also, I stand far away from anyone with tools. 👍

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      911 months ago

      Yup, buy most things at harbor freight the first time, if you break theirs buy whatever name brand fits your color scheme.

    • @teamevil
      link
      411 months ago

      That the Harbor Freight method. I agree.

    • @psud
      link
      311 months ago

      Regarding tools, buy a good size 2 phillips screwdriver straight off. You will use it enough to justify it, and the cheapest brands will damage screws

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      311 months ago

      I try not to use a lot of plastic wrap, but sometimes it’s the right tool for the job. I will always spring for the good stuff, generic is basically useless and you waste way more for inferior performance.

      • @Mango
        link
        111 months ago

        I work as QA in packaging and it turns out that it’s super important for a manufacturer to follow every little specification for consistency. There’s some seriously small details that make a big difference.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          211 months ago

          Oh I bet the line between “won’t stick to anything” and “immediately turns into a useless wad” is razor thin.

          • @Mango
            link
            211 months ago

            We use dimethyl sulfoxide to test for saran coating. We don’t really make cling wrap where I work though. That’s usually for anti fog or sealing layers.