• @TheFonz
    link
    341 year ago

    There is a vocal segment of Lemmy that can ONLY frame the world through the lens of class warfare and nothing else. That’s why they hijack every topic and thread with the same rhetoric. They have no plan, guidance or recommendations on what to do. They are only here to inform us about the ills of capitalism as if the collective psyche woke up yesterday and forgot all of history. They are so enlightened and privileged that they can’t help themselves in their need to share this valuable knowledge with everyone else. Capitalism bad. That’s it. Then they scuttle off to the next thread and start over. That’s the extent of “the Revolution”.

    • @LufyCZ
      link
      101 year ago

      Yes god thank you.

      I thought I was going crazy, every single thread that’s even remotely (very remotely) connected to politics is full of this.

      I’m seriously worried for the platform, because this shit is going to turn people off hard.

      Even saw someone suggesting an assassination of a supreme court justice AND PEOPLE WERE FUCKING DEFENDING IT. The mods removed the comment luckily, but I still managed to get like 30 downvotes on a “don’t suggest assassinations, be better than them” comment, just check my history.

      We’re becoming fucking Truth Social or Parler or whatever of the left.

      • @TheFonz
        link
        51 year ago

        I feel like it’s too late for Lemmy. The echo chamber is already pretty strong. I hope I’m wrong.

        • HACKthePRISONS
          link
          fedilink
          31 year ago

          the flagship instance is lemmy.ml

          the software is made by tankies.

          did you think this place was politically neutral? the whole fediverse is a fuck you to the status quo.

          • @TheFonz
            link
            121 year ago

            To be honest, I have nothing against socialists. I consider myself a soc Dem. I have many friends that are socialists. My issue is with how shallow and superficial the conversation is. Of your whole world thesis starts and ends with class warfare, there simply isn’t much to discuss. There are no prescriptions- just empty rhetoric. At the end of the say it’s horseshoe anti-establishment.

              • @TheFonz
                link
                101 year ago

                Why don’t you provide counterargument. Or interesting conversation. Anything to instill that it’s not just performative art form you guys.

                • HACKthePRISONS
                  link
                  fedilink
                  -61 year ago

                  this is some sealion shit. horseshoe theory is some middle school history class bullshit.

                  • @Telodzrum
                    link
                    21 year ago

                    Everything comes back to class with you people, doesn’t it?

                • HACKthePRISONS
                  link
                  fedilink
                  -71 year ago

                  performance art is a better use of time than shitting on people who challenges the status quo

                  • @[email protected]
                    link
                    fedilink
                    41 year ago

                    The problem is that you’re not actually contributing to the discussion. You’re just parroting talking points and actively turning people away from your stance by being annoying.

                    It’s not super dissimilar to what the trump cultists do.

        • @LufyCZ
          link
          21 year ago

          I’m trying to break through the echo chamber whenever I come across it, but it’s a thankless endeavor, and I’m pretty close to giving up.

          • @TheFonz
            link
            61 year ago

            There’s dozens of us haha. I think more people are tired of the empty rhetoric because it’s not getting the same traction it used to. My suspicion is it’s like the same three people posting the same comment everywhere.

            • @LufyCZ
              link
              -21 year ago

              Hand in hand with bots, possibly. I really want lemmy to succeed though, only thing driving me forward. Ah well, people haven’t used their brains in the past, no reason to expect they will in the future…

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        11 year ago

        I mean, I don’t advocate political assassinations, but I also recognize that the SC really doesn’t have any avenues for the people to remove a judge other than violence.

        A lot of problems would be solved if the people could call votes of no confidence.

        • @LufyCZ
          link
          11 year ago

          You can recognize it without suggesting anything, that’s completely fine in my book.

          And yeah agreed, it’s stupid that there’s no mechanism like that

        • @TheFonz
          link
          0
          edit-2
          1 year ago

          Can’t judges be impeached?

          Why are you downvoting? Judges can and have been impeached. The comment above implied this wasnt true.

            • @TheFonz
              link
              21 year ago

              This is so uncharitable. There’s a reason for this mechanism and it’s not true. The Senate was a democratic majority just a few years ago so it’s not impossible. The issue is we are always holding on by a thin margin to either the house or Senate. I don’t think we should be advocating for assassinations on Lemmy or any platform.

              • @[email protected]
                link
                fedilink
                01 year ago

                A supreme court justice requires a senate super majority to remove, and it’s never been done successfully.

                Again, I’m not advocating anything, but if a system of government is no longer representing the will of the people, actively working to hurt those people, and the people have no mechanism to peacefully recall a high ranking member of the government, especially a lifetime appointment, the only option left is violence.

                This is just a statement of fact.

                Honestly, I think the founding fathers did it intentionally.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      71 year ago

      Just as annoying are the “cars are bad” people who crawl out of the woodwork every time a car is mentioned.

    • Zorque
      link
      fedilink
      -31 year ago

      I mean, I recommend voting and being active politically and socially, but there’s always people who hate discussing politics at all and just want to live in their middle class bubble thats keeps on shrinking.

      But, sorry that people point out negative things in your vicinity, it must really suck when you’re taken out of your self-imposed apolitical safe zone.

      • @TheFonz
        link
        21 year ago

        What a stupid retort. Are you 12? “Being active politically and socially” whatever the fuck that means.

        I’m 38 and I moved to the US from eastern Europe. You know nothing about the life or hardship I endured under communist dictatorship.

        I welcome talking about difficult topics. Let’s do that. But let’s also not kid ourselves the vast majority of you guys are not interested in having those “difficult conversations” and are only here for the brownie internet points. You want to have the adult conversation? Let’s skip the moral grandstanding about capitalism and go straight to actionable items beyond being “politically and socially active”.