Let’s begin with the obvious: Duchamp’s Fountain really was a urinal. Not a painting or sculpture of a urinoir – though the latter might raise interesting philosophical questions – but the real thing, a token of a particular type – there were many visually indistinguishable urinals that came off the same production line. And just as importantly, Duchamp had no involvement whatsoever in designing or making the urinal that was the raw material for his artwork. His contribution was to sign the urinal, and exhibit it as art.
Indeed, the reason why this particular piece is more polarizing here than demonstrably more ‘modern’ works is because Fountain is famously regarded as one of the first examples of modern art.
This post seems to provide a good example of why this community being named ‘traditional art’ and not ‘non-digital art’ is confusing.
that’s a good point. the words traditional being a direct contradiction to modernism didn’t occur to me until reading this comment.
I don’t know if it’s possible to rename lemmy communities (since you’d have to change the url of the community, and if I only change the display name of the community, the discrepancy between that and the real name might be confusing)
but if it was possible to truly rename this community I’d want a name that emphasizes what the community IS rather than what it isn’t (i’m against names like NON-digital_art or NON-ai_art) but at the same time it’s hard to find an umbrella term that includes all art but explicitly excludes the digital medium (maybe Physical_art? I don’t know if that’s better or worse than Traditional_art.)
I don’t know if there’s a term that can escape people misunderstanding it.
Do people who didn’t originally understand how ‘traditional art’ was intended get ‘physical art’ easier? so many alternate terms imply things like a particular style or age of the work. physical is the most generic term, so that’s good, but the vibes are off for me lol. I’d get over it if others found it easier to understand.
Couldn’t agree with you more. But In the last 1007 posts or ever since the community’s been founded, I’ve only noticed people getting confused 6-7 times in total. Here’s to hoping the sidebar + the pinned post in the top is good enough to prevent further confusion. I suspect most of it comes from people who are seeing posts from this community on the all section for the first time.