Legal experts skewered Alina Habba’s “comedy of bumbling errors” in Trump defamation trial

Former President Donald Trump’s appeal of the $83.3 million verdict in the defamation case brought by E. Jean Carroll is unlikely to succeed, legal experts say.

“Let me ruin the suspense for everyone. Trump doesn’t have an appeal,” Nashville lawyer Brian Manookian argued Friday. “I know the talking heads on TV who have never tried a case or appealed a jury verdict have to mention it. Here’s why it isn’t going to fly.”

A person must “preserve a reversible error at the trial level” in order to have a case with merit on appeal, Manookian explained, ultimately blaming Trump’s lack thereof on his legal team in the case.

“This is why you hire competent counsel. You need someone who actually knows the rules of evidence and procedure,” he said. “Alina Habba had no clue what was occurring throughout the trial. She not only failed to preserve any remote grounds for appeal, like a moron, she repeatedly and unintentionally waived them over and over.”

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    2810 months ago

    Can he call for an appeal or mistrial based on inadequate legal protection or ineffective assistance of council?

    Is that a thing?

    • @evolatic
      link
      English
      5910 months ago

      Not in a civil trial. That’s only for criminal trials.

        • gregorum
          link
          fedilink
          English
          8
          edit-2
          10 months ago

          Having to put up 120% of the judgment amount in order to file an appeal might stop him, however. He probably doesn’t have that much cash lying around, and his properties may be tied up in other legal matters, so he might not be able to use them as collateral.

          • @formergijoe
            link
            610 months ago

            He’ll just use campaign funds and hope he becomes president so he can pardon himself for illegally using campaign funds

          • Overzeetop
            link
            fedilink
            110 months ago

            Saudis might sport a bond for him. They’re pretty tight.

      • Aniki 🌱🌿
        link
        fedilink
        English
        -8
        edit-2
        10 months ago

        You can appeal civil cases. Happens all the time. You constantly hear “jury awarded 1 billion dollars but was reduced to 50 dollars on appeals.”

        https://www.law.com/dailyreportonline/2023/12/07/what-if-the-jury-awarded-1b-ga-appellate-court-weighs-maximum-for-nominal-damages/?slreturn=20240030084445

        Is there an upper limit for a jury award of nominal damages? The Georgia Court of Appeals is set to weigh in after Walmart, represented by attorneys from Florida-based firm GrayRobinson, appealed a $1 million personal injury verdict on Tuesday, arguing the jury awarded nothing for pain, suffering or medical losses and $1 million is not a “trivial amount”—even if the defendant is Walmart.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          1910 months ago

          They didn’t say you couldn’t appeal a civil case. They said that ineffective counsel can’t be the basis of that appeal.

    • Aniki 🌱🌿
      link
      fedilink
      English
      610 months ago

      I think it can be argued by a competent appeals attorney but the likes of them working with Trump at this end-game are 0.