I once had a player that wanted a Decanter of Endless Water just to waterboard people 😳

  • Snailpope
    link
    511 months ago

    I would say yes, it’s a poket dimension with no air so the sound would have no medium to flow through. Thank you for coming to my Ted talk

    Seriously, super fun info for later!

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      911 months ago

      This is funny, I see your point but would rule the opposite. Because the bag wouldn’t be able to close due to a neck being in the way it wouldn’t seal the pocket dimension and I would rule the guard would still be able to breath (and scream) through the bag.

      • Snailpope
        link
        111 months ago

        I do believe you are correct, thank you for correcting me good sir

    • Björn Tantau
      link
      fedilink
      811 months ago

      It has enough air for one creature to breath for 10 minutes. And since the bag isn’t closed when it’s on the victim’s head there is a connection between the pocket dimension and the material world through which sound waves may travel.

      • Snailpope
        link
        111 months ago

        I do believe you are correct, thank you for correcting me good sir

    • @CookieOfFortune
      link
      111 months ago

      If there’s no air, wouldn’t it ruin a bunch of stuff you put in? Any liquids would evaporate, wood could deteriorate, etc. Is it also cold? That also causes changes to a bunch of stuff.