We’re not listening to the ones that are trying to separate themselves from the right.
My grandparents were proper red Labour (UK) socialists their whole lives, and my grandfather was also a vicar. While in retirement they left the church he had even done some services for simply because that church wouldn’t support gay marriage.
There are good people out there who are also Christian, and they are worth listening to.
Are they speaking out? I don’t hear any organizations critical of the church. Nobody is buying ads to denounce hate speech and bigotry. Maybe they are out there, but they aren’t being very loud.
Not at all what I meant. It’s just, think about the fact that, by definition, churches are organizations. It’s really easy to crowdsource funding when you have an organization with lots of members (or if you’ve been, say, pillaging and squirrelling away filthy lucre for hundreds of years.)
Now compare and contrast with a person who leaves a church after realizing the message in their book is different than the hateful message being spewed. A singular person can’t even begin to hope to fight the financial resource this campaign commands. There’s no special church for “people who are Christian who just realized their church was being hateful and changed churches” and even if there was, those people would be wary of joining a new church.
Sure, but with the sheer number of churches, you’d think the “good” Christians would all coalesce around one that is critical of the bigots and fascists who claim to speak for them. Surely in the roughly 2000 years of church history, there would be plenty of time for a “good” church to form and attract members.
People who leave hateful churches still joined them in the first place.
Right, but you’re just dodging the question by kicking it further back in time. Are all Christian churches bad? If not, then why aren’t more of them speaking out against the bad ones representing them? Isn’t their silence complicity in the hate propagated in their Lord’s name? Are we saying all Christian parents are bad for raising their kids in hateful churches?
I obviously refuse to generalize to “all churches bad” as I haven’t been to them. I can say that in my work, I take 2 disabled women to church on Sundays (I’m not a religious person but my job is to enable them to live their lives and they love the music and seeing their families) and their church has explicitly been saying things like “stop idolizing politicians” and “stop asking if someone deserves to be hungry and just feed them.”
I think people who never step foot in churches aren’t qualified to assume they all say the same thing and I think taking the view that they’re all evil is a little too convenient. If life were that black and white, it would be so much simpler.
We’re not listening to the ones that are trying to separate themselves from the right.
My grandparents were proper red Labour (UK) socialists their whole lives, and my grandfather was also a vicar. While in retirement they left the church he had even done some services for simply because that church wouldn’t support gay marriage.
There are good people out there who are also Christian, and they are worth listening to.
Are they speaking out? I don’t hear any organizations critical of the church. Nobody is buying ads to denounce hate speech and bigotry. Maybe they are out there, but they aren’t being very loud.
Not a lot of forthcoming money to amplify the voices of those who speak out against these churches, though.
All the decent Christians are poor? Only bad Christians donate money to churches?
Not at all what I meant. It’s just, think about the fact that, by definition, churches are organizations. It’s really easy to crowdsource funding when you have an organization with lots of members (or if you’ve been, say, pillaging and squirrelling away filthy lucre for hundreds of years.)
Now compare and contrast with a person who leaves a church after realizing the message in their book is different than the hateful message being spewed. A singular person can’t even begin to hope to fight the financial resource this campaign commands. There’s no special church for “people who are Christian who just realized their church was being hateful and changed churches” and even if there was, those people would be wary of joining a new church.
Sure, but with the sheer number of churches, you’d think the “good” Christians would all coalesce around one that is critical of the bigots and fascists who claim to speak for them. Surely in the roughly 2000 years of church history, there would be plenty of time for a “good” church to form and attract members.
People who leave hateful churches still joined them in the first place.
Or were born into them.
Right, but you’re just dodging the question by kicking it further back in time. Are all Christian churches bad? If not, then why aren’t more of them speaking out against the bad ones representing them? Isn’t their silence complicity in the hate propagated in their Lord’s name? Are we saying all Christian parents are bad for raising their kids in hateful churches?
I obviously refuse to generalize to “all churches bad” as I haven’t been to them. I can say that in my work, I take 2 disabled women to church on Sundays (I’m not a religious person but my job is to enable them to live their lives and they love the music and seeing their families) and their church has explicitly been saying things like “stop idolizing politicians” and “stop asking if someone deserves to be hungry and just feed them.”
I think people who never step foot in churches aren’t qualified to assume they all say the same thing and I think taking the view that they’re all evil is a little too convenient. If life were that black and white, it would be so much simpler.