You may have noticed a few of my posts here, I am very interested in self-hosting and what advice can you give to a newbie? maybe some literature, video, I don’t know~

  • @TCB13
    link
    English
    510 months ago

    Docker? Steep learning curve? You drunk mate?

    When it comes to software the hype is currently setup a minimal Linux box (old computer, NAS, Raspberry Pi) and then install everything using Docker containers. I don’t like this Docker trend because it 1) leads you towards a dependence on property repositories and 2) robs you from the experience of learning Linux (more here) but I it does lower the bar to newcomers and let’s anyone setup something really fast.

    In my opinion people should be very skeptical about everything that is “sold to the masses”, just go with a simple Debian system (command line only) SSH into it and install whatever is required / taking the time to actually learn Linux and whatnot.

    • @AustralianSimon
      link
      English
      4
      edit-2
      10 months ago

      I’d like to point out this is a hot take.

      Enterprise infrastructure has been moving to containers for years because of scale and redundancy. Spinning up new VMs for every app failover is bloat and wasteful if it is able to be put in a container.

      To really use them well, like everything in IT, understanding the underlying tech can be essential.

      • @TCB13
        link
        English
        -110 months ago

        Yes, that’s a valid use case. But the enterprise is also moving to containers because the big tech companies are pushing them into it. What people forget is that containerization also makes splitting hardware and billing customers very easy for cloud providers, something that was a real pain before. Why do you think that google, Microsoft and Amazon never got into the infrastructure business before?

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          410 months ago

          Why do you think that google, Microsoft and Amazon never got into the infrastructure business before?

          Amazon was in the infrastructure business well before containers were the “big thing”.

          • @TCB13
            link
            English
            010 months ago

            You’re missing the point.

        • @AustralianSimon
          link
          English
          3
          edit-2
          10 months ago

          What are you even claiming? Billing is the same ease VM or container.

          Cgroups became a thing in 2004 and then Google and Amazon started container offerings in 2008.

          And you don’t even need docker there are plenty of alternative engines.

          • @TCB13
            link
            English
            010 months ago

            What are you even claiming? Billing is the same ease VM or container.

            Before containers, when hosting was mostly shared stuff (very hard to bill and very expensive when it comes to support) or VMs that people wouldn’t buy because they were expensive.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      010 months ago

      Hmm I should maybe have added that I only ever touched docker cli tools and have never used a front end of any kind. I do know that they exists, but I like having my fingers in the mechanical room so to speak so it gave me a quite steep learning curve writing my own docker compose files from scratch and learning the syntax, environment variables and volumes working manually. I still to this day only use cli version of Docker because its the only thing I ever learned.

      • @TCB13
        link
        English
        -210 months ago

        writing my own docker compose files from scratch and learning the syntax, environment va

        But you know that most people don’t even do that. They simply download a bunch of pre-made yaml files and use whatever GUI. You would still learn more without docker.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          1
          edit-2
          10 months ago

          I can see that quickly becoming an issue if people just run random yaml files without understanding the underlying functions. I’m happy I never took that route because I leaned so much