• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    08 months ago

    Why the fuck are you making anti-Semitic statements? Why are you equating capitalist forces with “Rothschild’s”?

    Nah I’m more side-jabbing at Soviet antisemitism, dunno whether you share it it’s not a universal. Could’ve just as well said Deutsche Bank as far as the argument is concerned. “Oh no the filthy capitalist pigs invested into semiconductors we’re falling behind, they’re exerting authority over us” give me a break no they’re not your planners have their heads up their asses and missed the train.

    higher life expectancy than the US.

    Yeah saying “we’re better off than the US” is just as convincing as American saying “we’re better off than Haiti”. Darn low bar. Do better.

    not taking Engels Argumentation and exploring what he could’ve meant

    Why do you demand that of me, but not of Engels? Why isn’t he exploring what anti-auths could have meant instead of putting up a strawman? Also I did try to interpret Engels in a way where he doesn’t argue against a strawman but then the text makes even less sense.

    I agree UBI is paternalistic. The state will tell you how much you get to spend and need to use for living.

    Which is less paternalistic than giving you goods instead of money. In one case you can consume those goods, in the other you can choose which goods you consume. You can forego expensive food for a while to save up for canvas and paintbrush, if you so please. You can choose whether you spend the money included for purposes of recreation to travel to a metal concert, the opera, or a beach bar. You can choose to spend that recreation money on better food or a new hammer, if you so please.

    Is it anywhere close to usufruct? No, of course not. But it’s still miles better than “work for a boss or starve”, or “work for a boss or don’t get to choose your meal”. Don’t let the perfect be the enemy of the good.

    • carl_marks[use name]
      link
      fedilink
      18 months ago

      Nah I’m more side-jabbing at Soviet antisemitism

      Anti-semitism like stopping the holocaust, but ok go off king

      Could’ve just as well said Deutsche Bank as far as the argument is concerned. “Oh no the filthy capitalist pigs invested into semiconductors we’re falling behind, they’re exerting authority over us” give me a break no they’re not your planners have their heads up their asses and missed the train.

      What no theory does to a mf

      Yeah saying “we’re better off than the US”

      Do you even read? I said “Cuba despite it’s sanctions and restrictive access to world markets has a higher life expectancy than the US” Qualitative different statement

      Why do you demand that of me, but not of Engels?

      Because he’s dead?

      Why isn’t he exploring what anti-auths could have meant instead of putting up a strawman? Also I did try to interpret Engels in a way where he doesn’t argue against a strawman but then the text makes even less sense.

      “Strawman is when you use a definition that encompasses mine”

      Which is less paternalistic than giving you goods instead of money

      It’s paternalistic still? The economic base is capitalist and has a welfare superstructure. The undemocratic relation between worker and employer is not resolved and you get no say in how much you get.

      Is it anywhere close to usufruct? No, of course not. But it’s still miles better than “work for a boss or starve”, or “work for a boss or don’t get to choose your meal”. Don’t let the perfect be the enemy of the good.

      Sure, but once you have the political will to make UBI a reality, the huge amount of money you’re basically taxing off of the rich can be spent more ressourceful

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        18 months ago

        Anti-semitism like stopping the holocaust, but ok go off king

        Anti-semitism like this.

        “Strawman is when you use a definition that encompasses mine”

        It is if you expand the definition of fruit to encompass things that cooks would never call a fruit, and then call caprese a valid fruit salad. There’s a reason I led you down that road in the other thread.

        The undemocratic relation between worker and employer is not resolved and you get no say in how much you get.

        The employer also doesn’t get a say. The citizen overall, though, does get a say (in liberal democracies at last), as to how large the universal allowance is. The Labourer outnumbering the employer in the liberal democratic process thus gives an overall tilt towards the labourer, the ability to ensure that it’s large enough to be able to tell bosses “Shove it, I quit”.

        Sure, but once you have the political will to make UBI a reality, the huge amount of money you’re basically taxing off of the rich can be spent more ressourceful

        On what? Housing? People spend it on housing. They can pool it into cooperatives, no issue there regarding economies of scale.

        • carl_marks[use name]
          link
          fedilink
          18 months ago

          It is if you expand the definition of fruit to encompass things that cooks would never call a fruit, and then call caprese a valid fruit salad. There’s a reason I led you down that road in the other thread.

          It is if you expand the definition of salad… how are you not understanding this??

          I’m ending this conversation as it’s pointless.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            0
            edit-2
            8 months ago

            Anti-auths don’t have any issues with caprese We do have issues with fruit salads, though.

            …or something along the lines I lost track of the isomorphism it could be that we don’t have issues with fruit salads but have issues with caprese. But you’ll get it, eventually, as long as you stop confusing stuff by equivocating.

            • carl_marks[use name]
              link
              fedilink
              18 months ago

              I lost track of the isomorphism it could be that we don’t have issues with fruit salads but have issues with caprese.

              You’re such a joke