• @NewDark
    link
    1911 months ago

    localStorage is a thing, don’t need cookies for browser state

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      711 months ago

      Legally it’s the same thing. The ‘cookie laws’ don’t explicitly forbid cookies, any kind of tracking is prohibited. Also, just storing a cookie with the information that a banner was shown doesn’t require consent. The only thing that requires consent is tracking the user.

    • macniel
      link
      fedilink
      411 months ago

      Sure it is a thing but JavaScript on that domain can access it either injected or provided by the site. This is quite risky. Cookies can be http only so that client code cant access it.

      • @Zzombiee2361
        link
        711 months ago

        How is storing hideCookieBanner: false on local storage risky?

        • macniel
          link
          fedilink
          011 months ago

          What would the benefit of storing that in local storage?

          • @bighi
            link
            511 months ago

            Remembering that the user asked to not see that banner again.

              • @bighi
                link
                1
                edit-2
                10 months ago

                Because we were talking about how to save that information without using cookies. Setting a cookie would break the one thing that the conversation was about, wouldn’t it?

                If we’re in a fun conversation about how to enter your home without using the door, would you be the one saying “I have an idea, I have an idea: use the door”?

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  110 months ago

                  It was clearly a reference to the so called ‘cookie laws’ requiring permission for tracking cookies. However, cookies that are not for tracking purposes do not require any form of consent.

  • @Phoenix3875
    link
    1711 months ago

    At least for GDPR, if you are not storing users’ data, you don’t have to put a banner.

    • @bighi
      link
      711 months ago

      And even if you’re storing relevant user data, you don’t have to put a banner.

      You only need a banner if you’re storing data you don’t need, for tracking or other secondary purposes.

      • @devfuuu
        link
        711 months ago

        But companies actively want the end users to misunderstand and blame the law for making the internet so bad with the banners.

        Remember, companies only care about their pockets, not the people.