I’ve yet to make an account on Mastodon and I’m wondering, how good are its consistency guarantees? Do posts get lost? Will they eventually get to all federated instances?

From my Lemmy experience, posts do get lost here, from time to time. Is it the same on Mastodon?

  • @agedbeef
    link
    211 months ago

    I would say it depends on what you mean by eventually consistent. The simplest answer is that it has consistency insofar as databases and various queue technologies have consistency. That doesn’t account for the edge cases of federation and deletions of accounts/communities.

    • @DreadTowelOP
      link
      111 months ago

      Sure, I mean consistent in the following sense: will updates be eventually propagated even if the receiving server is throwing errors and/or is unreachable for some time? Do servers sync up?

      • @agedbeef
        link
        211 months ago

        Yea, so my understanding is that activity pub, the protocol used by mastadon (and lemmy) is serviced by queues, perhaps those like Kafka. Those sort of queues promise eventual consistency, which means when one goes offline, the queue is stored on the other, waiting until the other is online, in which case it resumes where the disconnected server last left off.

        • @DreadTowelOP
          link
          111 months ago

          In principle, yes. Lemmy, for now, only stores updates in memory, so if something goes wrong, they can easily go missing. How does Mastodon do it? I guess I’m asking about the implementation. I’m not familiar with Ruby…

          • @agedbeef
            link
            111 months ago

            Ahh, I can’t help with actual implementation. Sorry!

  • @DreadTowelOP
    link
    111 months ago

    TIL Mastodon doesn’t compress its API responses… And I was complaining about Lemmy’s verbosity…