• @rustyfish
    link
    257 months ago

    The same company that insisted for years that 30 FPS is better than 60 FPS insists on something stupid yet again.

  • @CitizenKong
    link
    21
    edit-2
    7 months ago

    AI is the new procedural generation, in that it will be touted as making the games more real and immersive but really only makes them boring and repetitive, thus stressing the importance of genuine creative handcrafting. I’m looking forward to smaller studios selling their games with a “no AI” pitch in a few years.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      46 months ago

      I’d say it’s just the latest innovation in procedural generation. But it’s still just that.

    • @Dkarma
      link
      16 months ago

      Nah it’ll make NPCs more interesting but $20 says they’ll get all racist and genocidey too.

    • Tekhne
      link
      fedilink
      16 months ago

      I disagree that procedural generation makes games more boring and repetitive. I think it depends on the game and how the procedural generation is implemented. Look at Noita for example - uses lots of procedural generation, mixed with some handcrafted elements, and it’s really fun! Terraria, another similar formula.

      Not my cup of tea, but a lot of people love No Man’s Sky for that reason - it’s fun to explore the crazy combinations.

      The original Elite was procedurally generated IIRC, and from what I understand it was super fun (before my time though).

  • Kushan
    link
    English
    20
    edit-2
    7 months ago

    If the game is good I’ll buy it, if it’s shit I won’t. I don’t see how these NPC’s will make the game good and I haven’t personally bought an Ubisoft game in several years.

    • @ThatWeirdGuy1001
      link
      17 months ago

      Quick question is it pronounced “you be soft” or “oo be soft”?

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        16 months ago

        It’s neither. The French “U” sound doesn’t exist in English so I can’t really give an example from an English word.

        That said, being a global company they’re probably fine with the default English pronunciation that would be “you be soft”.

      • @Odum
        link
        17 months ago

        “oo be soft” because they’re a French company (at least originally). The “you” sound for U isn’t really in their language.

        • @ThatWeirdGuy1001
          link
          17 months ago

          I’ve always said it with “you” but that makes sense.

          I was only curious because of the “an” before ubisoft in the comment I replied to. If it was the “you” sound it wouldn’t feel right to say out loud and it confused me lol

          Thank you for the lesson!

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          17 months ago

          It’s actually pronounced like the word Hue more or less (slightly shorter,the first half) it’s pronouced as such " hue - bee - soft "and the you sound is very much present in our language, for exemple baillou or caillou.

          • @Odum
            link
            26 months ago

            I just meant to say that it wasn’t typically a sound used for just the letter U, but fair enough! I stand corrected. I’ll gladly learn a lesson at the hands of a native lol

  • @slaacaa
    link
    10
    edit-2
    7 months ago

    It will make the shareholders richer, as you can fire a few writers and animators to save costs, and still sell a the game with shittier dialogue

  • @Nikls94
    link
    36 months ago

    But… AI is stupid. I mean it really is dumb. And on top of that, it’s just an amalgamation of things fed to it which in itself is nothing bad, but it limits itself massively when combining things.

  • @inclementimmigrant
    link
    36 months ago

    Replace “games” with “executives” and the sentence makes complete sense.

  • @TropicalDingdong
    link
    27 months ago

    Mmo game of were wolf or sheriff, but there are goal is to blend in the the NPCs

  • @Hackworth
    link
    -277 months ago

    Why all the salt? There’s been AI in video games forever. Is this a line people are drawing?

    • @TheFeatureCreature
      link
      English
      247 months ago

      For basic behaviour and pathfinding, yes. But aesthetics, outfits, dialogue, backgrounds, etc etc was all made by humans. The reason why NPC’s can feel so immersive and part of the worlds they exist in is because they’re made and written by the same people that made the rest of the game.

      NPC’s with awkward AI-gen voicelines spouting hallucinated nonsense that has nothing to do with the game or the player’s actions is going to be an absolute dumpster fire.

      • @QuadratureSurfer
        link
        English
        37 months ago

        There’s a place for AI in NPCs but developers will have to know how to implement it correctly or it will be a disaster.

        LLMs can be trained on specific characters and backstories, or even “types” of characters. If they are trained correctly they will stay in character as well as be reactive in more ways than any scripted character could ever do. But if the Devs are lazy and just hook it up to ChatGPT with a simple prompt telling it to “pretend” to be some character, then it’s going to be terrible like you say.

        Now, this won’t work very well for games where you’re trying to tell a story like Baldur’s Gate… instead this is better for more open world games where the player is interacting with random characters that don’t need to follow specific scripts.

        Even then it won’t be everything. Just because an LLM can say something “in-character” doesn’t mean it will line up with its in-game actions. So additional work will need to be made to help tie actions to the proper kind of responses.

        If a studio is able to do it right, this has game changing potential… but I’m sure we’ll see a lot of rushed work done before anyone pulls it off well.

      • @Zehzin
        link
        07 months ago

        But is it gonna be a worse dumpster fire than the usual Bethesda game generic NPC barking its one line of dialogue at you?

        • @TheFeatureCreature
          link
          English
          97 months ago

          Potentially yes as at least the Bethesda NPC will say lore-accurate lines.

          Or line.

      • @Hackworth
        link
        -57 months ago

        Pathfinding was an absolute dumpster fire for a long time. Remember dreading any gameplay where you had to lead an NPC somewhere? Things take time to get better. Gotta start somewhere.

    • @IzzyScissor
      link
      167 months ago

      “Please help me! I need someone to take care of 6 large rats that live in my kitchen!”

      ‘OK! Where are they at?’

      “I’m sorry, but as an LLM, I cannot provide specifics on details pertaining to this request.”

      • @Hackworth
        link
        -87 months ago

        Why would you train an NPC LLM to know it’s an LLM?

        • @IzzyScissor
          link
          107 months ago

          The best models right now still hallucinate, so no matter how well trained, they’re still going to be awful. The specific message isn’t the issue.

          They have no object permanence and you can convince them of things by just repeating it to them enough times. But the worst part?

          They’re not even fun to talk to.

          • @Hackworth
            link
            -17 months ago

            So if they don’t hallucinate, have object permanence, and are fun to talk to, you’re all good with gen AI NPCs?

            • @IzzyScissor
              link
              77 months ago

              Those are not my ONLY issues, no. They’re the most egregious for a videogame right now, but the entire concept is just … Fluff for no reason other than to list “AI NPCs” on the box.

              Paying for more writers is simply better all around.

              • AnonStoleMyPants
                link
                fedilink
                27 months ago

                I don’t get it. Actually well working AI NPCs sound fucking amazing. To have an actual conversation about anything in the game by typing your questions? That’s like the wet dream of an RPG.

                Have writers write the background info, some lore stuff, “books” about stuff in the game etc.

                I want to have a conversation with all the NPCs and choose from four premade questions about a quest I am on.

                And yes, obviously they have to work well or they’re extremely awkward and anti-immersive.

              • applepie
                link
                fedilink
                16 months ago

                Paying for labour is toxic to any self respecting capitalist

              • @Hackworth
                link
                07 months ago

                And do you believe paying for more writers will remain a better option for the foreseeable future?

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      157 months ago

      no, there hasn’t. What games called ai has nothing to do with the generative ai bullshit of today

    • @Duamerthrax
      link
      97 months ago

      Map path finding isn’t remotely similar to LLMs.

      • @Hackworth
        link
        -117 months ago

        They’re both A.I. Yes, they work very differently, but the goal is the same - simulate intelligence.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          57 months ago

          No. Just. No. One is just a complex logic gate with a bunch of if, the other is a generative ia. Those are two VERY different things. It’s like comparing a rc car with a cargo baot, they are simply nothing alike.

          • @Hackworth
            link
            English
            07 months ago

            Which AI is the RC car?

        • @Duamerthrax
          link
          27 months ago

          Does a pocket calculator count as simulating intelligence? You should work on simulating intelligence.

          • @Hackworth
            link
            English
            -36 months ago

            Is Doom running on the calculator?

            • @Duamerthrax
              link
              26 months ago

              yes

              But you don’t seem to understand the difference between a simple Turing Machine and a Machine Learning models.

              • @Hackworth
                link
                English
                -26 months ago

                I understand them both well enough to implement them in my projects. I don’t see why people are anything other than excited about the implementation of more capable AI in games. Are these initial implementations garbage? Probably, but that’s just growing pains, So what is it about gen AI that actually bothers people?

                • @Duamerthrax
                  link
                  16 months ago

                  So what is it about gen AI that actually bothers people?

                  It’s being used corporate suits to replace talented artists, writers, programmers, and voice actors and make their shareholders happy. Although this is Ubisoft, so they already making substandard products anyway. I mean, how do you fuck up the login system for your online table top games as much as they did?

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              26 months ago

              Ah yes now that you made a fool of yourself you start acting like one to play it cool. You really out did yourself on the personal development today didn’t you ? :)

              • @Hackworth
                link
                English
                -26 months ago

                The salt runs deeper than I expected.

      • @Hackworth
        link
        57 months ago

        Now that makes sense to me.