• FuglyDuck
    link
    English
    1295 months ago

    this seems illegal.

    Assuming somebody other than google owns the phone (The individual, the carrier.) that now becomes theft.

    • Sabata
      link
      fedilink
      225 months ago

      They have enough money to be above the law.

    • Kairos
      link
      fedilink
      -36
      edit-2
      5 months ago

      I don’t think it is because TOS. It would become illegal if they insinuate otherwise (such as stating they will send back your phone once they’re done such as in advertising.)

      Edit: oh right warranty restrictions/regulations never mind.

      • FuglyDuck
        link
        English
        745 months ago

        Do you really not send your phone off for repair without the expectation that it’s returned when the repairs are complete?

        Refusing to service modified hardware is one thing. Keeping the device is theft, and no ToS has the power to change that.

        • @hoshikarakitaridia
          link
          225 months ago

          Reminds me a bit of ASUS’ current bold strategy to hold customers ransom over their graphics cards through pressure and deception.

          Sounds pretty unenforceable to me.

          • bluGill
            link
            fedilink
            295 months ago

            Magnuson-Moss comes to mind. non oem parts cannot be used to deny warranty coveragi

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            125 months ago

            The same ones preventing me from opening “Joe Bob’s Pet Grooming and Laptop Repair Emporium” and then stipulating on the 3rd page of the TOS that I get to take ownership of anything that arrives on a Thursday.

          • @frickineh
            link
            115 months ago

            One would assume all the laws against theft. Because that’s what it would be.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    325 months ago

    This is one of the many reasons why I advise people never to buy anything directly from Google and always go through a retailer. You basically have zero recourse with Google. If a retailer screws you over you can at least charge back as a last resort but Google has your account hostage. What can you do if they just decide to pull some bullshit like this?

    • @wreckedcarzz
      link
      English
      175 months ago

      This was the straw that broke yada yada, and why I moved my data out of G a few years ago. If I pulled a cb and they axed my account, I’d lose some gift card info in gPay (that I have backed up in bitwarden), some YT uploads, and the general account, but nothing of value.

      But most people aren’t in my situation, unfortunately.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    325 months ago

    This behavior isn’t unique to Google either; Samsung and Apple also engage in similar anti-consumer conduct. For example, in the report about Samsung mentioned earlier, it was found that Samsung requires independent repair stores to disassemble a customer’s product if it has a non-OEM part.

    wat

    Give me a break OEMs wtf

  • @jordanlund
    link
    -175 months ago

    I can’t see anyone using non-OEM parts sending their device back to Google, they’ll just use their shady local fix it shop.

    • @Sanguine
      link
      175 months ago

      Explain what is shady about a local electronics repair shop.

      • @jordanlund
        link
        55 months ago

        Have you seen many local electronics repair shops?

        • @pivot_root
          link
          115 months ago

          I wouldn’t call the repair sweatshops used by OEM manufacturers any better. Fix it yourself.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            65 months ago

            Yeah, but they fucking glued the battery to the screen!

            On that note, anyone know any good repair shops in the Twin Cities? My LG G8 needs a new battery.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            1
            edit-2
            5 months ago

            “This thing is shit, but something exists that is worse, therefore this thing is good now!”

            • @pivot_root
              link
              25 months ago

              “This thing is shit, but something exists that is worse~~, therefore this thing is good now!~~ Fuck the system, I’ll do it myself.”

              FTFY.

    • Farid
      link
      fedilink
      95 months ago

      I think you got downvoted because the way you said it implies that all 3rd party repair shops are shady. But it’s true, that the vast majority of repair shops are shady in places that I have lived.

      • @jordanlund
        link
        15 months ago

        A step above vape shops, but not that big of a step. ;)