• @AlbinoPython
    link
    10116 days ago

    They’re gonna drive that thing till the wheels fall off.

  • @Boddhisatva
    link
    7416 days ago

    And the little bugger is still chugging along. Amazing.

    • @LifeInMultipleChoice
      link
      316 days ago

      That thing hasn’t even traveled 20 miles I think. Going to say it must be getting a lot of damage from winds or something. Someone said it is aluminum.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        815 days ago

        Martian winds can’t damage anything at all. Actually that’s the main reason why rocks are super sharp, and cause this much damage.

        • @LifeInMultipleChoice
          link
          215 days ago

          Yeah I was wondering that, they always talk about storms, but the rockz would have rounded out.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        215 days ago

        I think by “mileage” Indy meant less “distance traveled” and more “use” or “wear & tear”.

  • @dejected_warp_core
    link
    40
    edit-2
    16 days ago

    What I’m curious about is the “engineering model.”

    All NASA missions have duplicate probes, satellites, rovers, here on earth. They’re essential for testing various scenarios like training astronauts (in the case of the Hubble repair missions), or testing the limits of the systems in question. I wonder if the engineering model for Curiosity has one of its wheels cut away in the same pattern, to simulate difficulties in navigation and traction?

    • Flying SquidOP
      link
      2816 days ago

      Maybe that’s why the took the photo of the wheel?

    • tiredofsametab
      link
      fedilink
      1216 days ago

      iirc, they did use a damaged wheel to try to figure out a situation where a rover was stuck, though I don’t remember any details about it.

  • Mossy Feathers (She/They)
    link
    fedilink
    3616 days ago

    Man that wheel is so much thinner than I was expecting. I was surprised it was broken at all until I noticed how thin the material is. That looks like it’s less than a quarter of an inch of what appears to be rigid material for something about the size of a medium-ish car.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      2215 days ago

      It was just thick enough to hold well past the initial mission time. That means any thicker would have been a waste of materials, weight, and energy. If anything, it was too thick. Every gram counts when bringing objects to space.

    • @stupidcasey
      link
      1716 days ago

      It’s thicker than it looks because the rover is much larger than it looks of course proportionally it’s still thin but curiosity is lighter than it looks because it was made for space snd mars is smaller than earth.

    • Altima NEO
      link
      fedilink
      English
      6
      edit-2
      15 days ago

      It was getting damaged pretty much as soon as they started using it. It’s kinda weird they didn’t catch something like that in testing on earth? Were the rocks on Mars just that more jagged?

      But also I think the wheels are aluminum as well, so very soft metal.

      • @Zron
        link
        2116 days ago

        Designing any kind of space vehicle is always a trade off.

        The vehicle needs to be light enough to be launched from earth to mars, but durable enough to fulfill its mission goals.

        I’m sure if nasa had access to a vehicle that could send an M1 Abram’s sized, solid steel rover to mars, they totally would, but that would probably cost more than a moon mission, and the whole point of rovers is that they’re fairly cheap for the amount of research you can get out of them.

      • Cethin
        link
        fedilink
        English
        616 days ago

        It’s lasted this long. I think they made the right decisions. No matter what it is, it’s going to be damaged. The goal is to make it still operate despite the damage for as long as possible. The goal isn’t to make it last forever, or to never be damaged. The more massive the wheels are the less mass everything else can be, so it’s a big trade-off.

        • TFO Winder
          link
          fedilink
          615 days ago

          It has travelled 32.39 km (20.13 mi) on Mars as of 19 September 2024

        • Altima NEO
          link
          fedilink
          English
          215 days ago

          Yeah but I recall them having signs of damage early on that they didn’t expect to happen.

      • @Madison420
        link
        215 days ago

        Yes rocks are more sharp on planets or moons with no or very little atmosphere because erosion by wind/rain forces is reduced.

  • @SlippiHUD
    link
    English
    1016 days ago

    You’re saying we’ve polluted Mars with microplastics too!?

        • MentalEdge
          link
          fedilink
          74
          edit-2
          16 days ago

          They’ve lasted quite well.

          But it’s apparently one of the things the designers want to do better with future rovers.

          The design was meant to be light-weight while providing good traction on the martian surface, but it has turned out more fragile than they’d hoped. All six wheels on Curiosity are quite damaged.

          The wheels on Perseverance are still aluminium, but instead of the zig-zag tread, the large gaps of flat metal that have been getting punctured, were done away with. The wheels on Percy instead have a dense pattern of wavy tread.

            • MentalEdge
              link
              fedilink
              1916 days ago

              You’re welcome! Percy and Curiosity are magnificent machines! There’s a ton of fantastic content out there about their design and engineering. Smarter Every Day and Real Engineering both have videos about them.

              Most people also don’t realize how absolutely HUGE they are, until they see a person stand next to one of them on video or in a picture.

              • @[email protected]
                link
                fedilink
                English
                7
                edit-2
                16 days ago

                I had the opportunity once to see Curiosity modeled in a VR environment as if you were standing on Mars next to it and I remember how very surprised I was at how big it was.

                As a fun side note now that you’ve jogged my memory. That same demo also had a model of the Rosetta spacecraft orbiting Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko. For whatever reason it was sized so that the asteroid comet was about the size of a cat and I will never forgot watching that itty bitty little satellite orbit around that odd shaped asteroid comet in front of me.

                https://www.aam-us.org/2016/02/23/experiments-in-virtual-reality-at-the-museum-of-flight/

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            316 days ago

            Fascinating! Thank you for including a picture of the new design, using the ribs to reinforce the surface should improve things a lot with minimal material added.

    • @dejected_warp_core
      link
      1116 days ago

      Not just Mars, but yes. Biodegradability isn’t even a factor since there’s no biosphere to speak of, which also raises philosophical questions like: “what is pollution, exactly?”

      What will really bake your noodle is to imagine a future where we settle the Moon and Mars. Do old space program artifacts become monuments and parks (debris and all), or are they trash to be removed from the environment?

      • @DrownedRats
        link
        616 days ago

        Knowing humans, yes! I think they will. Probably not the bits that fall off, they’ll most likely be placed in the visitors centre but given how sentimental we are as a species I can absolutely see us one day touring the sea of tranquility space reservation.

      • @BigDaddySlim
        link
        English
        316 days ago

        Removed, obviously. Gotta put that new STARbucks somewhere

    • Flying SquidOP
      link
      1116 days ago

      It’s okay, Mars is low on fossil fuels and could use some global warming, so the Martians are already burning it as we speak.

  • @Sam_Bass
    link
    915 days ago

    typical humanity dropping plastic pollution on another planet before ever setting foot on it

  • mechoman444
    link
    215 days ago

    The guy that tied up the wiring on the side there is looking at this photo (probably) and saying to himself: that wiring I arranged is on motherfucking mars and that’s just crazy.