Like, I love thrash/death/heavy metal music, but I could mostly do without the vocals. Is there a genre of music (or specific bands) I should look for?

I’m a big fan of Arcturus, Children of Bodom, etc, but I prefer the instrumentals way more than the singing.

So, is there a specific genre for that?

Edit: Imagine Silent Night, Bodom Night but without lyrics. It’s not that I dislike the vocals; would just appreciate the track more without them. It’s like they’re just in the way of what I want to hear.

Edit 2: Thanks, everyone. I have heard of Animals as Leaders but am not super familiar with them. Will definitely check them out as well as the other recommendations.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    551 month ago

    Just to be clear; are you wanting heavy metal music that’s only instrumental? Or are you wanting heavy metal music where the vocalist doesn’t sound like a small angry demon with a cold that just got karate chopped in the throat?

  • @PineRune
    link
    34
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    For instrumental music with no vocals, try: Wide Eyes, Invent Animate (their instrumental versions), Modern Day Babylon, I Built the Sky. These aren’t quite Death Metal, but they have really complex guitar and drum pieces.

    For with vocals: Sea in the Sky, Ignea, Unleash The Archers, Corelia (also has instrumental version of their 1 album)

    • @GrabtharsHammer
      link
      161 month ago

      Unleash The Archers’s version of Northwest Passage is a real banger.

    • @Kelly
      link
      English
      51 month ago

      OP might want to play around with everynoise.com.

      For Wide Eyes it lists one of their genres as instrumental djent, then they offer a sample of each artist that is also tagged with that genre.

      It can help explore a niche further or discover adjacent niches.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    25
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    You might like some of Haken’s heavier stuff. They’re primarily prog but they go hard, too.
    Try the album Vector and the album Virus.

    From Virus i recommend you try the song Prosthetic
    and the song Messiah complex V: Ectobius Rex
    From Vector I recommend you try the song Puzzle Box
    and the song Veil

    Their new album Fauna is really good and has a good mix of different styles which includes heavy elements as well.

    Come back if you like them I will recommend more!

    🤘 Haken! 🤘

     

    It’s also okay if you don’t like prog, i recognize it’s too different for some. lol

    • @Masta_Chief
      link
      51 month ago

      Haken (pronounced “hay-kin”) is fucking awesome. They have a pretty wide range of sound too so most people who like metal I think would enjoy their songs.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      12
      edit-2
      1 month ago

      Ok, you got my upvote because I love some Buckethead but…

      this is a deep well, you and I know it. Please give OP (and me) the “death metal without the screaming” album(s), if you know the titles. I know I have heard two at least that fit this bill exactly but haven’t found them yet. I have been searching tonight but you start listening to Buckethead and there goes the time.

  • @Meron35
    link
    171 month ago

    Power metal is more traditional metal but with clean vocals (no growls). Bands include DragonForce, Angra, Helloween, Stratovarius

    There’s also progressive metal, where the emphasis is more on the intricate instrumentals, so some banda don’t do growls. It is usually less heavier than traditional metal. Bands include Dream Theatre, Liquid Tension Experiment, Symphony X, Tessaract, Haken, frost*, Porcupine Tree

    • @brygphilomena
      link
      5
      edit-2
      1 month ago

      Rhapsody’s Holy Thunderforce is just so damn entertaining.

      And Helloween’s Eagle Fly Free is pretty high on my list.

    • @kalpol
      link
      51 month ago

      I don’t know where the Hu falls in this but don’t leave them out

    • @abysmalpoptart
      link
      2
      edit-2
      1 month ago

      I was thinking this as well, add in some bands (album suggestions in parens) like epica (holographic principle), kamelot (epica/black halo), Symphony x (divine wings of tragedy), and even a band like battle beast (circus of doom) or unleash the archers (apex) and i think op will have a good time

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    111 month ago

    Give a listen to Testament! IMO the music is thrash so heavy it borders death metal, and the singer ventures into growling only occasionally. My gateway drug into Testament was their Titans of Creation album.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    91 month ago

    I mostly listen to death-doom rather than strict death metal, but there’s a fair bit of that out there. My two faves in the genre:

    Draconian has clean female vocals alongside growled male.

    Swallow the Sun has a wide range of vocal styles, but getting increasingly cleaner pretty much every album (along with clean female vocals on a lot of tracks).

    Again, this is death-doom so a lot of the stuff will be a little slower-tempo than straight death.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    81 month ago

    So there’s a lot of ways you can go with this. You can definitely find instrumentals of death metal bands, but you can also try something new.

    Haggard is one of the best in symphonic metal, and while there’s still a stitch singer, imo they’re MUCH easier to understand.

    Native Howl has slayer played by some country boys on banjo and guitar. They also do a bunch of their own stuff that sounds pretty wild. “Thrash grass” is one of their better albums and pretty accurately describes their flavor of fusion (thrash metal played in the style of bluegrass)

    Older Arch Emeny stuff is also quite good, and having a pretty lady growling at me is a novel experience. Angela gossow also shows up in metalocalypse so that’s instant bonus points

    Dethklok does pretty well at straddling the line between melodic/symphonic/death metal, and if you like the metal without Nathan explosion you can check out Brandon Small’s other stuff where he isn’t growling like a cartoon character.

    Last but certainly not least is The Lord Weird Slough Feg. Exquisite technical metal wrapped up in an 80s/90s power metal package. I simp for Slough Feg wherever I can because it’s EXCELLENT metal that doesn’t get nearly enough recognition

  • SSTF
    link
    8
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    You might like a lot of stuff by The Sword.

    Example

    There are vocals but they are smooth and crisp rather than the xtreme death metal habit of trying to eat the mic.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    8
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    I am also not a fan of super growly vocals. There’s a lot of stuff I love musically but the vocals put me right off. I’d listen to bands like Opeth and Beyond the Buried and Me more often if the growls weren’t present.

    If you’re looking for metal with cleaner singing, I second the suggestions for Unleash the Archers and Nightwish. I can also recommend Blind Guardian, though the singer’s voice is polarizing. One of my favorite metal singers is John Bush from Armored Saint. He also did a few albums with Anthrax in the 90s.

    For instrumentals, I can’t recommend much aside from guitar virtuosos like Steve Vai. Occasionally bands will release instrumental versions of their songs as B-sides, bonus discs, etc. Might be worth checking into.

  • @Olap
    link
    81 month ago

    Elder

    Dvne

    Bossk

    Keygen Church

    Julie Christmas

    Cult of Luna

    Sgàile

    Nightwish

    Skiltron

    Glorryhammer

    Creeper

    No real death in that list though - the vocals are part of the genre

  • Jeena
    link
    fedilink
    English
    8
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    Hm, Animals as leaders? But it’s not very thrashy.

  • @mushroomstormtrooper
    link
    71 month ago

    Animals as Leaders, Thessa, Pomegranate Tiger, Myth of I, and Fractalize are great ones.

    Stoort Neer and Vildjharta both have some really good instrumental albums.

    Gore., Monolord, '68, and The Damned Things are all a little less heavy than what you might be looking for, but they are all great and have mostly clean vocals.

    Polyphia and Chon are also both incredible but probably fall a little closer to something other than Metal.