On tabletop I play a Way of the Astral Self Monk with defensive duelist. I thought I’d try that in the game and switched Astarion to open hand Monk. I’m not sure if I’m doing something wrong but it never seems to activate.

  • @LordPassionFruit@lemm.ee
    link
    fedilink
    English
    63 months ago

    I don’t have an answer for you, but would defensive duelist work with a monk? Doesn’t it require a weapon in the main hand and an empty off hand?

      • @uid0gid0OP
        link
        English
        23 months ago

        Why do you think open hand monks can’t use weapons?

          • @uid0gid0OP
            link
            English
            1
            edit-2
            3 months ago

            I don’t want to be a contrarian, but I can’t find anything in the PHB that says you can’t wield a weapon. Unarmed strikes don’t even need to be made with your hands. Is it a sage advice that I’m unaware of or something?

            • Björn Tantau
              link
              fedilink
              English
              43 months ago

              They are talking about BG3. There you cannot make a regular unarmed strike while holding a weapon.

              There are many significant differences in the rules between BG3 and 5e.

              • @uid0gid0OP
                link
                English
                23 months ago

                I’m realizing this more as I play the game. Shield Master not allowing you to shove people prone is one that really annoyed me.

      • @LordPassionFruit@lemm.ee
        link
        fedilink
        English
        13 months ago

        I was aware monks can (at the very least I was aware of Kensei), I’d just never considered it as advantageous enough to go Defensive Duelist, I guess.

        In an MP save I’m in, I’m playing an open hand monk and am currently using that staff you can buy from Auntie Ethel in the grove because of the bonuses to unarmed damage.

    • @uid0gid0OP
      link
      English
      23 months ago

      Defensive duelist only requirements are a finesse weapon with which you are proficient. No mention is made of an empty off-hand.

  • teft
    link
    English
    5
    edit-2
    3 months ago

    Your fists aren’t finesse weapons so it can’t possibly work. Also fists aren’t considered weapons for feats so second point for it not working for monks.

    • @uid0gid0OP
      link
      English
      23 months ago

      I have a +1 short sword for the weapon requirement

      • teft
        link
        English
        6
        edit-2
        3 months ago

        If that’s the case it should work. Are you actively wielding the sword when you’re hit? Having your bow out will cause melee reactions not to trigger.

        Also is the reaction actually turned on? Go to the reactions section of your character page and make sure it’s actually set to trigger.

        • @uid0gid0OP
          link
          English
          3
          edit-2
          3 months ago

          Having the bow out might be the problem since I usually start combat with him shooting someone at long range. I’ll check on that

          • teft
            link
            English
            53 months ago

            I bet that’s it. I used to have the same problem with opportunity attacks not triggering on my gloomstalker for the same reason. I had to train myself to always swap back to his swords at the end of his turn.