Summary

The Senate passed the Social Security Fairness Act in a 76-20 vote, sending it to President Biden for approval.

The bill repeals the Windfall Elimination Provision and Government Pension Offset, which reduced Social Security benefits for nearly 3 million retirees, including teachers, police officers, and postal workers.

It also restores full benefits for surviving spouses and families of these workers.

Though backed by bipartisan support, some Republicans opposed the bill due to its $195 billion cost over a decade. Advocates hailed it as a victory for public service workers.

  • archomrade [he/him]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    1010 hours ago

    My parents were urging me to write my rep over this, but I think this is misguided at best

    These two provisions were addressing a real issue with how SS benefits are calculated - typically your monthly benefit is a percentage of your average monthly earnings eligible for SS. Higher AIMEs are indexed down more than lower ones on a principle of need (those with lower lifetime earnings are likely to need more of a benefit to live through retirement). These provisions basically addressed fringe cases where low AIME’s weren’t necessarily a result of low earnings but of switching out of SS eligible income into a pension system

    As I understand it, these simply indexed the monthly benefit down based on (largely outdated) assumptions about those earners. As others have pointed out - SS already has a solvency problem (it’s been undermined for decades now), and further stressing that fund without expanding the tax base is just going to further stress it at a time when the GOP is itching to cut it across the board.

    No question that our retirement system needs to be expanded, but this particular change seems reckless. I have to wonder why they chose to do this now

      • @Rapidcreek
        link
        1011 hours ago

        Pretty sure hemeant it in jest.

          • @Rapidcreek
            link
            510 hours ago

            Maybe even older people can retain a sense of humor, while others never get one.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              210 hours ago

              True. Betty White was hilarious until the end. Schumer, on the other hand, has never been known for great wit…

              • @[email protected]
                link
                fedilink
                English
                39 hours ago

                I’ve seen some witty remarks from him over the years. One of my favorites was when Republicans wanted to make it illegal to burn THE FLAG (gasp). Schumer was quoted something like: “I wish these people cared as much about what the symbol represents as much as the symbol itself.”

      • Kairos
        link
        fedilink
        2
        edit-2
        10 hours ago

        Sarcasm is hard to discern over text. Especially when journos don’t bother to mention the speaker’s tone.

  • @danski
    link
    312 hours ago

    What effect does this have on the solvency date?

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        59 hours ago

        As a millennial I can’t wait to receive the social security I’m paying into right now. I’m foaming at the mouth with excitement.

      • @danski
        link
        29 hours ago

        Thanks for the info!

    • @otterpop
      link
      611 hours ago

      I feel like this would accelerate that a bit. While this increases fairness in the system it’s putting it further at risk in my opinion. They need to get rid of the cap, it’s absurd to give someone already making massive amounts of income a break when the system is in need of more funding.

      • @BrianTheeBiscuiteer
        link
        18 hours ago

        Vitriol aside is this not accurate? I mean, I wouldn’t say it’s “doomed” but I also don’t think either side has the guts or political capital to save it.

  • BoofStroke
    link
    fedilink
    English
    213 hours ago

    … For people who get a government pension. I don’t think this is good legislation unless the person needs to stop work for long term disability.

    • @Rapidcreek
      link
      1612 hours ago

      They pay the Social Security tax, so they shouldn’t get the benefit?