“The new station will play a curated selection of songs based on what you’ve been listening to but haven’t heard before.”
Looks interesting. To me, Apple’s curated playlists have always been superior in quality to Spotify’s but they really don’t have as vas of a selection of curated playlists. Apple Music stations are often excellent, too, if you know how to crate them.
It takes Apple forever to add obvious features like this but I’m glad they have. I’ll use it a lot.
Call me an Apple sheep, but they usually get it right when they finally get around to something.
There are exceptions and I think Apple Music is one of them. They’ve been playing catch up with Spotify. I only have Apple Music because it’s with the bundle of everything else.
Edit: grammar
That’s interesting. I had Spotify for a couple years and absolutely hated it. Moving to Apple Music was a much more enjoyable experience for me.
I tried to like Apple Music but the compatibility Spotify has with all my various speakers around the house is in a whole other league compared to Apple Music. If all I had were apple speakers, I’d probably use it.
Ahhh, that makes sense. My google home and Alexa’s integrate with Apple Music so when I need to listen on one of those I can. But that’s rarely how I listen. I’m either in AirPods or using my desktop monitors. I feel like for my use cases Apple Music seems to have better sound quality.
I found much better playlists on Spotify and you could make shared lists with friends. Those were the two biggest things I is.
They’re actually adding shared playlists in iOS 17.1 (finally). As for playlists, I think it’s just up to your own preference
Yeah, I’m not a playlist guy at all. All my friends tell me I’m lame and that it’s like a better version of the mixtape but to me a playlist has never been analogous to the mixtape or burned CD. With those formats you had quantifiable time limits so you had to be very selective about what went on them.
I’m an album purist at heart, I understand I’m in the massive minority but it is just who I am.
I personally like to switch music services every year or two when things start to feel stale
Can’t argue with that. I used to do similar. I just found after moving to Apple Music from Amazon and Spotify that I haven’t wanted to leave. I’m not constantly bombarded with podcasts when I’m trying to listen to music (looking at you Spotify) and that’s been a big UX improvement for me. I might try Tidal again at some point but when I tried it initially it was a bit clunky.
Agree on this. I dropped Spotify after the Rogan fiasco and switched to Apple Music. It’s not as good but I refuse to go back to Spotify. I really hoped that Apple would have a great product but the interface isn’t great and experience has been less than great. Happy to hear they are finally putting some resources into improvements.
*There
Not this time. I have found about 3 new (to me) country songs I like and my discovery playlist is full of nothing but twangy country , which isn’t even the genre of the new songs I do like.
Did people forget about Pandora? That’s basically what Pandora was, at least back in my day. back creaks
yea, for those not paying attention … the “enshitification” has been a slow development for a while now. There was a moment back circa 2010, before google stopped being “not evil” and when the iphone/smartphone was still new and web pages were capable of doing anything and problems could be solved with apps etc etc … that tech just seemed “good” and to be doing “good”, and there were reasons to think so. But good things have been falling away slowly for years and big things turning shit too.
Has enshitification already reached “gaslighting” status where people just use it when it’s not appropriate?
Merely inappropriate usage of a word isn’t gaslighting. Ironic really.
There’s a reason I put it in quotation marks, it was an example not a part of the sentence
Pandora wasn’t only focused on stuff you haven’t heard though. It was a mix. It’s actually closer to the Apple Music “personal station”.
We don’t get that in the UK so it’s never really been an option for us unfortunately
Ok good, but I still lack some kind of “incognito” listening mode. Spotify doesn’t have this either.
I listen to music I like and then I have other music on for “cover” och concentration, like bland non engaging things in the background to cover up other intrusive noise, like family or co-workers.
Having these to fairly opposite genres mixed together isn’t a great experience when it comes to history or discovery functions.
Being able to easily exclude music/playlists would be great from these types of features.
And having another account isn’t an option since we are maxed out of subscriptions.
There is an option in Settings to use the music history played on this device (whether phone, iPad, or AppleTV) which sounds like the kind of toggle you are looking for. The setting is on by default but you can turn it off temporarily when playing something you don’t want influencing your algorithm.
Awesome, a bit cumbersome to get to but seems to be the feature I need. Thanks!!
I miss human DJ’s.
To be more specific, I miss the left-of-the-dial 11pm variety.
And Shoutcast-style radio with live DJ’s. I still spin up a stream every now and then, but it’s not the same as it used to be.
Apple music has a sort of halfway point in the form of Radio. Pre-recorded hour or two of actual radio
Check out nts.live
This is great, thank you.
Twitch is pretty great for that.
I’ve found Soundcloud to be a great alternative for this. Loads and loads of 1-2 hour mixes, and great exposure to a whole range of new music. Only issue is that some of (what I enjoy anyway), seems to have very limited releases and isn’t necessarily available on Apple Music/etc.
I used it today for 8 hours and damm, I must say that it is quite good. Definitely better than the “keep playing song when playlist ends” or the curated weekly lists. I had to skip songs only few times and I didn’t mark ANY as “dislike”, where I often that to do so few times in a row on the other options.
Perhaps a change in how I use Apple Music made this better, cause I learned from some comment here or on Reddit, that the algorithm acts better if songs are marked as love/dislike to tell it the taste, not like in Spotify where it just goes along the lists or what I listened to in the past.
I have been using endless shuffle for a few years now that keeps playing songs based upon what is being played.
I start a playlist and it keeps playing until I realise it might have gone a bit off track.
It would be great if they would give some love to the apple music preview app for windows 11. It is a source of constant frustration for me, with regular crashes, wild volume changes and overall sluggishness. Sadly it’s only slightly better on macOS
Cider 2?
About time!
I thought this is what my weekly New Music Mix playlist was meant to do.
It is. But this one will just go on forever. Not entirely sure what the point of having a station and a playlist is 🤷♂️
I really want to like Apple Music more but I don’t know why they don’t allow you to follow radio shows like: https://music.apple.com/au/curator/beats-in-space-with-tim-sweeney/1573950910 and be notified of latest mixes? Unless I’m just missing something and the feature is already there?
deleted by creator
Oh so you’re supposed to select “Add to Library” than “Love” to keep them. I just moved from Spotify and YTM and I’m used to clicking on Like/Heart to save music. That’s kind of confusing.
Yeah, the “Love” only affects future recommendations and you can’t see songs you’ve loved (except if they’re on your Library and you use the Mac app). I lost a really great song that I just Loved instead of adding to library and could never find it again :(
It’s a bit late, but hey I will take it still. I tend to have pretty bad luck with discovery apps as I have narrow musical tastes, but I will give it a shot for a while.
I have had the most luck with the custom Apple Music stations honestly, seems to have the best balance of songs I know and like with newer stuff in the same vein. I am not sure I would spend as much time on a playlist entirely composed of new things.
I have narrow musical tastes
Tell me about it. So often … I’m thinking to myself … “sighs … it’s not about the genre … it’s about being good”.
There’s this song from a Dutch band that I like, but when I start a station with it, I just know it will misinterpret the reason why I like that particular song and inevitably it’ll start playing random songs by Dutch bands.
Apple surely can see the complete catalog of The Who that I have in my library, including the vinyl albums that I’ve ripped. Not that the Music app could see it, but Apple could also see the eye-watering amounts of money we’ve spent on tickets to watch 75 year old men prance around on stage (via the tickets from the last three tours in Wallet).
So what’s the first song played on this new Discovery station? “Who Are You?” by…wait for it…The Who. Whether you’re a Who fan or not, is there anyone walking this planet over the age of 21 that hasn’t heard that song?
deleted by creator
Joe Pera
I tried it today and liked it so far, only one skip. For the most part it was “adjacent” to things I’ve listened to, and brought in a couple of new offerings. I have been really into the “My Station” stuff since it basically plays me an array of the things I already love, but the “Discovery” mode is interesting and I’ll probably use it here and there to add likes to the algorithm for better suggestions.
Will be interesting to see what it suggests I discover. Currently it thinks I’m really into dababy and maroon 5, which aren’t my taste at all.
Spotify added an AI DJ that usually works well, except for when it plays an artist I “used to listen to a lot but not so much recently” and then 5 Machine Gun Kelly songs come on. I’ve listened to him for about 30 seconds in total the 6 or so years I’ve had Spotify and it was only out of morbid curiosity when he released a “punk” album.
Though their discovery Playlist is on point for me.
Sick, hope it works well
