- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
You must log in or register to comment.
Perhaps, they added, Apple could add a warning message when using the Control Panel toggles that alerts the user that tapping on its Bluetooth icon doesn’t completely shut off Bluetooth and their iPhone can still interact with proximity-activated beacons, such as Bochs’ contraption.
Apple will never do that because if enough people disable Bluetooth on their iOS devices, it’ll reduce the effectiveness of Apple’s Find My network.
I have little doubt that apple still uses things like wi-fi and bluetooth even if they are completely turned off. I complained when they made the change to the control panel. If I want bluetooth or wifi off, no button I push should turn it off partially or for “24 hours.”
Well yeah, they’re pretty open about that.
It’s still running in low power mode when you turn the phone itself off so that I can still ping the Find My network. And it says this when you go to turn the phone off.
“They’re pretty open about that” doesn’t quite cut it, when I’ve seen examples in this lemmy post alone of people discovering the fact. We need removable batteries.
A removable battery wouldn’t do anything about it. They would just include a little unremovable CMOS battery that would be used to power the Bluetooth while the device is off or the main battery is removed.
The entire point of it is so that you can use Find My when the phone is off. If it’s lost, or stolen and they turn the phone off, it can still be found in Find My.
It’s not just that. When connected to an Apple Watch or Apple Pencil (for iPad) the quick toggle maintains these connections along with maintaining handoff and continuity functions between personal devices among other things. In these cases, I think having the quick toggle not fully disable Bluetooth makes more sense to prevent new connections while keeping the existing Watch and Pencil Bluetooth connections active to preserve functionality. Of course, I get that not everyone’s use case is the same, but I rarely need to fully disable the wireless radios. Particularly with Wi-Fi, I use the quick toggle to temporarily disconnect Wi-Fi if I’m on a bad connection away from home. When I return home or to my car (for wireless CarPlay), my phone will reconnect to the respective networks without me needing to remember to re-enable.
Yeah if you go to DEFCON keep your phone off lmao
Half the fun is seeing how people try to fuck with you, and fucking with them back. Burner phone, though, never a real connection that you care about.
And once again, the weakest link in the security chain are humans…
Which humans are you blaming exactly?
I don’t think it’s fair to blame the users. They toggle bluetooth off and think it’s off. How are they supposed to know “Bluetooth Off” means “Only some amount of Bluetooth is off”?
And I don’t think designing a convincing phishing device is that much of a leap in logic. Bluetooth is off, so maybe the notification is legit from apple and needs authority for a connection?If you blame the designers who left a backdoor in the bluetooth, then yea that’s fair.
How are they supposed to know “Bluetooth Off” means “Only some amount of Bluetooth is off”?
When bluetooth is on, the icon is blue. When connecting is off, the icon is white. When bluetooth is fully off, the icon is grey. The same goes for wifi. It even gives you a
.That’s not new.
Thanks, I never used an Apple Product, so I didn’t have the contextual infromation!
To me it sounded like a binary state (on/off), as I know it from most phones I’ve seen.I still think it’s unfair to blame the user. Apple design is not as consistent or as intuitive as touted. Their UI still has lots of hidden features, inconsistent behavior and strange decisions.
Just had to use my wife’s iphone and felt like a moron trying to navigate it.
I don’t know the gestures, the last iOS device I supported still had that center home button.
It wasn’t always like this. It started somewhere around the iPhone X I think. It used to actually turn off wifi/bt in the menu.
Before the iOS overhaul, you went Settings>Bluetooth>Toggle to turn off BT. That still works like it did before. But what most people do now is just swipe from the top-right and tap the shortcut.
Yea the control center used to turn them off. Apple changed it to “disconnect until tomorrow” in iOS 11. So iOS 7-10 it functioned fine.
Perhaps, they added, Apple could add a warning message when using the Control Panel toggles that alerts the user that tapping on its Bluetooth icon doesn’t completely shut off Bluetooth and their iPhone can still interact with proximity-activated beacons, such as Bochs’ contraption. So they are saying “off” isn’t really off if you do it in the control center, you have so go into settings to completely turn it off.
I don’t know if it turns itself black on (blue) when something is trying to connect.
I was indeed blaming the end users. Yes, the bluetooth off thing on apple devices is super annoying and I don’t know why they still force it…
Bluetooth is off, so maybe the notification is legit from apple and needs authority for a connection? The thing is, why would you connect to an Apple TV when you are not at home? Or share your password with another device when nobody asked you in person (e.g. WiFi password)?
Form my understanding, this falls into the same category as phishing SMS or mails. You as a user need to know if this is legit or not.
The target audience for this are not people here on lemmy… it’s our parents, grandparents and more in generally people who are not tach savvy… and/or just don’t care.
This is why we need to make people aware of this and teach them how to respond, basically not to click on everything you see. I’m still doing this in my family and I’m very proud of my 80 year old grandma, that dodged a few very convincing scams. :)
And haha, I never thought of backdoors, but yes, they are also produced by humans.
A promiscuous bluetooth connector is not a user problem other than their response to it. Why is it happening in the first place?
Unlike real Apple devices, his contraption wasn’t programmed to collect any data from nearby iPhones, even if the person tapped and accepted the prompts. But, in theory, they could have collected some data, according to Bochs.
deleted by creator
My brother you just explained a 20 step prep to have a method to turn off Bluetooth which should be done so by the tap of a button.
It’s a useful feature to be honest.
It meant to be used when you want to disconnect temporarily.
Lets say you are connected to a cafe wifi and want to browse a website but at the moment the wifi is slow or the site has issues with the wifi. At this time, you want to temporarily disconnect from the wifi then do whatever you want to do.
You don’t need to turn it back on. It’ll turn on automatically. You don’t want to realize that you’re using cellular data after you watch 1 hour of a 4k video.
Same applies to bluetooth.
It’s a two-step process to turn off bluetooth on an iPhone. Swipe down from the top to get to the menu, tap the bluetooth icon.
Well, reading the article and the comments, it seems you are wrong.
So you’re saying the way I turn off bluetooth on my phone doesn’t turn off bluetooth on my phone? I’m really confused here. It takes one down swipe at the top of the phone to access this menu. In every app.
So you’re saying the way I turn off bluetooth on my phone doesn’t turn off bluetooth on my phone?
Yes. It doesn’t turn it off completely, only partially. It stops your phone from connecting with some devices (headphones, speakers etc.) but not from connecting with others (smart TV’s, Find My-enabled stuff etc.)
In order to turn it completely off you have to go to the Settings.
I see. Thank you.
Did you read the text or are you just randomly commenting?
I’d like to test this.
