Yesterday I went to a football game in person and I had a great time. Everyone was enjoying the game and it was a close matchup. I realized halfway though how nice it is to just watch a game without commentators taking endlessly the whole time. I use to think commentators made the games more exciting, but the game is plenty exciting without these dudes talking the whole time.
I would watch sports that were just the game and nothing else. Sure you can mute the TV, but I don’t think you should have to miss out on the full experience because some old dude who played the game a lifetime ago won’t shut up.
I see why players hate the media. Games are fun without media people.
Second Audio Program FTW. See if your feed has the ability to turn off the commentary. Some sports feeds are just natural souund on their second channels.
Look for audio track options.
For example, I know F1 always has a track that has no commentary.
All soccer games that I watched on TV had several audio tracks - default was commentary, but usually there’s also at least a second track with just the stadium ambience and sometimes for big events even more tracks with different commentary like especially focusing on tactics or alternative casters if you do not like the main caster.
i don’t know if this is a thing or not, but it should be if it isn’t. they need a standard for broadcasting multiple audio streams, like different languages or directors commentary, which could include sportscasters as well. then the consumer could make their own choices on what they hear. someone get to work on that and give me all the credit kkthx
Some e-sports do this. I haven’t watched the DotA International in a while, but several years ago they would have streams in English, Chinese, and a few other languages IIRC. Just looked up the most recent one and they have vods in English, Russian, and simplified Chinese. They also had an English newbies commentary stream that explained what was happening in more detail, though I can’t find that on the most recent one.
That’s been in place for decades.
Dang - I thought this was my million dollar idea, but it looks like I’m 15 minutes late and am infringing on your multi-stream audio patent.
I would pay so much for ufc with fucking Rogan or DC on commentary. They are so shit it actually ruins what would otherwise be an entertaining fight.
I want to add to OPs statement with the exact opposite point.
I absolutely, positively loathe football (as in the actual ‘sport’ where kicking a round object is the point, not handegg, which is equally pointless, but easier to escape back here in Yurp).
A long time ago, I listenedd to a football match on the radio. That was quite a fun performance of the commentators. It was some world cup game of our team versus some other randos, but they were really into the game, which was fun to listen. Also, they sounded as if they had drunk several litres of espresso. Therefore I would like to state that professional football should either be televised without commentary (as long as I can avoid it) OR broadcast on radio with decent commentary.
While I do not watch the sports ball, I have heard that if you mute the center channel on a 5.1 or 7.1 speaker setup, it’ll mute the commentary. Speech is usually piped through the center channel only for clarity. I’ve had this happen by accident on movies, t.v., etc.
This may have changed. I am not sure. I do not watch the sports ball. I do not want to watch the sports people injure each other for money. It makes me sad, and it makes me sad that you do not care.
Some of the sports people I’ve known in my life watched games on tv with the sound completely off and possibly with subtitles, so I don’t think it’s an unpopular idea with many viewers. That also seems to be the case when I see sports on at my local pizza places.
My million dollar idea is that instead of smart tvs spying on us, why not have like 3 audio channels to choose from? Witty banter channel for who ever is into that, stats and no nonsense for the super serious, and explain-it mode for people like myself who will watch occasional basketball or hockey games, but only has a slightly more than “basic” grasp of the rules and don’t know all the players, their stats, or why we care that the team we’re not playing against currently is winning or losing.
Your idea costs money. Spy TVs make money.
My parents had hockey season tickets. There was a gentleman in front of us who had the game in his ears while he was watching the game in person. I don’t know if it’s truly unpopular, but everyone has their own preferences. For that guy, the commenters enhanced his experience. For you, they detract.
You can try disabling the center speaker on your home setup.




