I mean, when you visit Japan or South Korea: its like as if they have zero tolerance for obesity (since most clothing stores do not accomodate plus size as they cater to slimmer builds a lot more) while clothing stores in America or Britain have plus size options. It depends, if someone who is “fat” visit either JP / SK: there may be some people who disdain “plus sized” individuals as they’re not used to seeing people who are obese.

Its 100% the western diet. I mean you see obesity rates go up once its introduced.
USA drive your car 10 miles for a giant soda and a bearclaw donut.
Asia, walk a block to the local market for tea and small treat.
Way too broad a brush and there are lots of overweight and obese people in Japan. But, generally speaking
- smaller portions
- traditionally diets were heavy on veg, fermented things, fish, seafood, etc.
- traditionally, food was made at home and eating out was not super common
- people are walking and moving a lot more than in most of the US
- people are getting nutrition info and education with proper meals in their schools
I live in the countryside in Japan where a lot of younger people eat pre-prepared garbage and drive everywhere, so we have plenty of unhealthy people here as well. The ones who live in the cities tend to do better, but diets are definitely worse than they were 40 years ago.
It’s definitely a cultural thing with different diets, with ridiculous beauty standards thrown in too.
East Asian food is pretty different from Western styles, you will usually have less deep fried stuff and hyperprocessed food (not to say that doesn’t exist, many brands of processed snacks are very popular in East Asia!). There will often be more vegetables and, depending on where you are, seafood, in East Asian diets, and in general a stronger variety of food when you are growing up.
But there are also immense beauty standards at play, culturally people are pressured to be slimmer. Speaking from personal experience, there is a lot of behind your back gossip from peers, parents, etc. when another kid is “plus sized”
People have also mentioned that people walk more in East Asia, visiting street markets is very common, for instance.
You know, Okinawa had the worlds highest life expectancy. Then after ww2, American stuff started seeping in. And their life expectancy started reducing. They lived mostly a vegan life eating few or no processed foods. Then after ww2, they started americanising. And yeah, their life expectancy started going down for the first time in recorded history.
People have also mentioned that people walk more in East Asia, visiting street markets is very common, for instance.
I know diet matters more than exercise but I definitely felt a difference moving from Europe to Canada. I walked way more in Europe than here and I just feel worse …
Damn that girl under the Korean flag is depressing to look at.
Eating disorders are scary.
If you look into this you’ll see that most of this has to do with wealth and prosperity. Developed nations see obesity rates increase before plateauing.
This paper talks about the effect https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-026-10383-0, and also has a great graphic showing how east Asia’s rate of obesity is accelerating faster than places like the US (meaning they’re catching up to places like the US).
I’m sure l, due to cultural differences (driving, food, etc.), the regions won’t ever be exactly the same, but this data shows prosperity leads to some glut.
It’s slightly different for each culture but they share similarities:
JP: From a young age you are taught how to eat right, exercise, and do general maintenance every day. Because of the socialized healthcare system, every person gets a ‘grade’ on their health, literally a letter grade, per the 2008 Metabo Law. If your grade is too low, you will not only have doctors hounding you literally every single check up about it, but you can be excluded from jobs (not fired, but there is no anti-fat discrimination laws in the hiring process). Because of the nature of Japanese culture, this also means there is huge societal pressure to not be fat so you are not a burden to others, and so you won’t be shamed openly – because they will fucking shame you. As others have mentioned there’s also just more walking no matter where you are. Cars are expensive luxuries, not a necessity.
SK: Beauty Standards dictate weight, and are generally relaxed for rich men. There isn’t a Metabo law, nor health grade, but instead the societal pressure to meet beauty and fitness standards for the dating scene applies the social pressure. The fact most of the population is urban, again, also helps. Cars are luxuries, not a necessity. Additionally the mandatory military service tends to even out the population in terms of fitness. It’s easier to stay in shape once you’ve been in shape.
ZH: Chinese schools drill fitness into you and parents can be fined if they allow children without medical issues to get too fat (depending on the type of school the parent chose for them, if it’s an all-day school then the school would be fined). This, alongside the historical trend of mostly labor-intensive jobs being available has created the general setting of people being in-shape; and there is a pretty intense culture in the elderly to stay in shape (since retirement age is lower than any other developed country, they want to enjoy their time.)
Most of SEA: Walking. Also free medical. Also poverty.
Anecdotally so take it with a grain of salt, I will say that of all the people Ive met from South East Asia(Ive only met 4 so ya there is a bias here) every single one of them said that they or their parents were skinny not due to diet , exercise, how often , how long they walked or anything else except for poverty. That was the ONLY reason. Most of them y dont even get to choose how much of their pay goes towards food… the only choice is just forced on to them…
eating garbage and sitting on your ass all day = get fat
asians don’t consume nearly as much sugar and fried food, plus they walk more
people in the west who follow the same pattern are also generally not fat
The answer is shame culture.
Source: I’m Chinese American… my mom keeps calling me fat, even my aunt who’ve been in the us for several decades was like “yeah you should lose some weight so I can introduce some girls to you” 💀
(I’m 24 for context, I’m like around 5’6 and 5’7, 210 pounds)
Oh yea theres a lot of gossip amonst Chinese people. Like I can hear my mom on wechat be like “omg that guy/gal is so tall/short and he looks fat/skinny af” and lots of “ugly” judgements (Do western households also do that?)
Oh yeah my older brother is like 29 years old so my mom is doing the Asian parent thing of “omg look at you, so far ang ugly, how are you gonna get a girl to marry you?” (context: he recently went to China and did not find a match, despite owning a house and has the opportunity to immigrate to the us, as my brother is a US Citizen. So my mom is just constantly criticizing him on the appearance. (oh yea btw you basically need a house and an impressive job to get a Chinese girl to marry you))
Edit: Oh yeah I just remembered. This is not Asia vs Europe but China vs USA specific. So… in China, lots of buildings have no elevators. We used to walk up 5 floors of stairs to get to our small apartment (very shitty apartment btw). In contrast, here in the US, it’s either a townhouse or your apartment is probabbly modern enough to have elevators. So you dont “have” to walk stairs. My aunts in NYC live in apartments with elevators, so yeah I havent basically done any “stair climbing” since arriving in the us, except like short 1-3 floors in smaller buildings like hospitals, small offices, and schools.
Not sure how to break it to you, but 5’6 and 210 is pretty unquestionably into the obese category. She might be an asshole, but she’s right.
Yeah I know, but I’m already suicidal enough, honestly I kinda wanna try weight loss drugs.
I don’t want to sound like Jordan Peterson but exercise is definitely helpful in several ways.
But you also need to want that change, and it’s hard as hell to want it when you’re depressed. I understand that feeling.
The weight loss drugs are part of a toolset. I don’t think it should be the first line option, given your age.
Personally I woild recommend against those peptides or weight loss drugs cause since youre young (and Im guesisng youre uninjured) there are better alternatives to losing weight like increasing your ‘basal metabolic rate’ through resistance training or cardio training (or just do w hat I did and do both) . And trust me I know that youll tjink that things like weight lifting and calisthenics or gymnastics will not help you with losing weight since itll make you gain muscle but forreal though the best way to lose weight is to gain muscle. Ive gained a ton of muscle over the last about 3 years and I can say my metabolism feels impossible some days. Increased muscle has allowed me to unconciously keep weight off. Its the stupidest thing but it works. lol
You said that you were suicidal . What do you think makes you feel suicidal? Is it the gossip that your parents say about you? Well if its from your parents thats awful and they should feel ashamed for gossiping about you in that way. They should be more loving of their own son espcially if you live with them. They should give you time for your peace and quiet. All humans need peace and quiet. If its cause of what other people say or think about you? Ill say those peoples’ opinions on anythign doesnt matter at all. Most of those people watch Palestinian and Sudanese kids get blown up everyday and theyre just ‘A-OK👌🏻’ with this current status quo. Heck, some of those people took a paycheque to go and blow up some kids - https://www.palestinechronicle.com/who-are-the-foreign-nationals-fighting-in-israels-war-on-gaza-report/. So what does their opinion matter if theyre as inhumane and deranged as that?
Dont let idiots make you hate yourself more than you already do…because theyre idiots is basically what I feel about things.
Best of wishes 🫂
Fuck that noise, youre ensuring your body has the required nutrients and theres nothing wrong with that.
Being skinny just leaves your body less runway when things to go wrong. Unless anything specific is causing mental or physical harm, youre young and absolutely have no reason to stress.
Obviously try to stay away from the preservatives and processed goods as much as the finances allow, but using weight loss drugs is just another subscription down the hole.
So?
Mentioning it isnt going to change anything, if it even needs changing. Stress eating is a hell of a common eating disorder.
And shit they could just be buff as hell, weight to height ratio (BMI) alone is useless.
I guess you’ve never heard of Sumo wrestling. Japan literally invented a sport where being fat is beneficial.
I recently saw a clip of Sumo, and thought they looked a lot less fat than I remember. I know that it’s more muscle than the average person, but they still didn’t look out of place for a Walmart
I think it’s really just the difference between being large and being unhealthy. The 350lbs Walcreature probably isn’t anywhere near as healthy as a 350lbs sumo wrestler that builds muscle under the fat and actually does exercise and likely eats rather healthy, just in larger portions.
Ah yes! Cause THE MAJORITY of people in East Asian countries’ peoples are sumo wrestlers…rather than… a tiny ass percentage of them…
Also Im sure that future studies will prove that the average sumo wrestler unsurprisingly has better musculature and cardiovascular health than the average Wal-Martian lol





