• @apfelwoiSchoppen
    link
    57 months ago

    Reductive. Neoliberalism protects and foments fascism as we ratchet a little further to the right each election cycle.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      157 months ago

      The reason why the rachet turns further to the right each election cycle is because non-conservatives in the US have an abysmal voter turnout.

      Neoliberalism is the product of leftists deciding not to vote because there’s no “good” option, and leftists will perpetuate this cycle by refusing to acknowledge incremental progress as a good thing.

      • @hark
        link
        197 months ago

        If only there was a way to increase voter turnout, like giving voters what they want… nah, that’d make too much sense. The democrats are too smart to give people what they want.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          2
          edit-2
          7 months ago

          Democrats do that. They appeal to centrists because those are the people who turn out to vote.

          Leftists don’t get representation, the ratchet turns right. Funny how that works

          • @hark
            link
            167 months ago

            Or maybe the centrists turn out because they’re the ones that democrats appeal to. Obama ran on a progressive campaign and won big in 2008, so it’s clear that it works. The problem is that he then immediately turned around and instituted centrist policy as usual.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              67 months ago

              Same thing with Biden. Ran on $10,000 of student debt relief for everyone, improving the climate, and not being Trump. People figured they could push him left, that was the argument. Now he’s been a lot better than I thought he would be admittedly. But still, the student debt relief has been extremely targeted, he made foreign electric cars more expensive, and he’s materially supporting a genocide while yelling at the protests against it. If they can’t push him left in 4 years, then the theory was proven wrong, candidates can’t be pushed left, and it’s right for leftists not to vote for them. Democrats don’t feel they have to move left because leftists have no other choice about who to vote for, so I get the calculus on their parts, but it’s becoming dangerous.

              It also depends on how much supporting a current genocide is a red line for someone. That seems to be the biggest difference I see in these posts. Some people can’t bring themselves to vote for someone who does that no matter what. Others seem to be more malleable and forgiving about it. I know which one I am, but honestly, no judgment on either. I waffle between them myself. I don’t feel nearly as much pressure as others,though, because I don’t live in a swing state, so my vote doesn’t matter.

            • @PugJesusOP
              link
              English
              -107 months ago

              Obama ran on a progressive campaign and won big in 2008, so it’s clear that it works

              God. It’s fascinating how little self-proclaimed leftists remember 2008.

              • @hark
                link
                127 months ago

                Which part am I wrong about? Obama ran on affordable healthcare, abortion rights, being anti-bailout for too-big-to-fail entities, and being anti-war. He won a supermajority. Then he scaled back his healthcare plan, said abortion rights “aren’t a top priority”, continued bush’s bailouts and added more, and invaded/bombed more countries during his term.

                • @PugJesusOP
                  link
                  English
                  -87 months ago

                  Obama passed the best affordable healthcare plan he could.

                  On abortion rights, he was no more left than Hillary. On the bailouts, he was openly in support of the Bush bailout plan even before the election. On war, Obama was openly in favor of the continuation of the war in Afghanistan and harder military policy against several countries, some of which even McCain wasn’t onboard on.

                  But hey, whatever helps fuel your delusional “If only candidates were more left, then they would DEFINITELY win in a landslide!” outlook.

                  • @mydude
                    link
                    77 months ago

                    The democrats are all moderate republicans, which in itself is an oxymoron. Don’t believe me, here is Obama saying just that (about himself); https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZJIlZxHfclc Now imagine you somehow get total control of all braches, and to top it off 3 weeks filibuster proof. You can do anything, but you don’t really want change. What do you do? Well implement RomneyCare, call it ObamaCare and leave out the public option, which will ensure it be a giveaway to big pharma. Seems good at first glance, but leaving out the public option really killed it, as they intended.

                    Regarding roe…

                    The first thing I’ll do as President is sign the Freedom of Choice Act https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=BdrOrwmk78Y

                    Im pro choice https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=nmzdkAbu8dY

                    Not my highest priority https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=RxiDZejZFjg

                    parody… No https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=1z4uhxpOnN0

                  • NoIWontPickAName
                    link
                    fedilink
                    67 months ago

                    Obama had full control of both houses and the White House, they could have passed whatever they wanted.

                    Instead we still didn’t get single payer healthcare.

                  • @[email protected]
                    link
                    fedilink
                    57 months ago

                    Obama was really good at letting people project what they wanted on to him politically, while still broadly holding to the neoliberal agenda, and lots of people were insanely naïve at the time. I mean, you had people who claimed to actually expect the election of Obama to usher in a post-racial epoch in the USA, as though all the racists were going to say, “Aw, shucks, the black guy won? Well, hang it up boys, we have to face reality and accept we’ve been wrong all along.”

                    He also benefitted from pretty excellent political cover from criticism, where, like many vocal Biden supporters are doing right now, any criticism of him would be associated with outright support of the vilest opinions espoused by the GOP at the time. If you said “You know, this Obama guy isn’t as great as he’s being made out to be,” you’d have people assuming you were some nutjob that thought he was secretly Kenyan, or whatever other crazy conspiracies the Tea Party folks trotted out. I don’t think it was purely malicious or cynical attempts to discredit people all the time, but there was a big chunk of people who wanted to believe in their conception of Obama, which couldn’t admit that he wasn’t the savior sent from on high to resolve all the country’s problems in exactly the manner they had hoped he would.

        • @someguy3
          link
          -17 months ago

          Good god. You win elections from the center. A center vote that switches from R to D is worth double because the R loses one vote and D gains one. You literally win from the center.

          If you want the center to move, then make the Dems win overwhelmingly and consistently in President, house of reps, and senators.

          • @hark
            link
            57 months ago

            So do you think republicans are catering to centrists with their full dive into fascism or do you think only democrats need to appeal to “centrists” for some reason?

            • @someguy3
              link
              27 months ago

              Trump won by appealing to the manufacturing jobs sector, and because of the protest Hillary vote. As much as I want to believe people were/are informed about his fascism, they really aren’t.

              And now, because Trump won one election, the whole Overton window moved right. You know, because he won an election. You want to move the Overton window? Vote.

              • @[email protected]
                link
                fedilink
                27 months ago

                Biden won an election more recently than him. Weird how the Overton window moves when Republicans win an election but not when Democrats do. Wonder if there’s a reason for that.

                Hell, Bernie (and Warren) moved the widow more by running in a primary than they did by winning.

                • @someguy3
                  link
                  17 months ago

                  The reason is because Dems have to actually do things like pass legislation. Which more often than not requires all 3 of house, senate, and president. All the GOP has to do is block things and yell immigrants. Progress takes, you know, actual work. Stagnation or regression takes next to nothing.

        • @PugJesusOP
          link
          English
          -127 months ago

          like giving voters what they want

          Funny enough, giving voters what they want is inevitably decried by Very Serious Online Leftists

      • @apfelwoiSchoppen
        link
        87 months ago

        Neoliberalism exists for many reasons. But blaming leftists is strange. We would be a lot better off if voting was not so hard for black and brown people, for instance. We can at least agree on that.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          -17 months ago

          Yeah, I’m on board with making voting easier for everyone. Voter turnout is ultimately the only way short of violent revolution to fix shit in this country.

          Voting is difficult enough for people who don’t vote conservative, which is why when leftists refuse to vote out of principle because their perfect candidates aren’t a choice, they’re figuratively stepping on the rake.

          • @apfelwoiSchoppen
            link
            2
            edit-2
            7 months ago

            Totally agree about voting and its need for ease. But I can tell you more leftists vote than don’t, I can promise you that. Systemically that’s not the biggest problem. And I certainly plan to vote and I won’t be helping Trump with it.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              0
              edit-2
              7 months ago

              I hope you’re right, but I’ll say that I’ve definitely seen more people in this election cycle say there’s no point in picking between two fascists than any other cycle I’ve been a part of. Especially here on lemmy

              • @apfelwoiSchoppen
                link
                -2
                edit-2
                7 months ago

                Yeah totally. Social media is bashing and circlejerking, even in the open source spaces. Not the best lens into reality.

      • NoIWontPickAName
        link
        fedilink
        57 months ago

        No one will vote for our shitty candidates.

        Should we run better ones?

        No blame the people for us not having a good candidate

    • @PugJesusOP
      link
      English
      77 months ago

      Even if we assume for the sake of the argument that your ridiculous assertion is true, “Let’s do fascism faster” is exactly the kind of bootlicking take I would expect from a tankie.

      • @apfelwoiSchoppen
        link
        -4
        edit-2
        7 months ago

        Never said I was a tankie bruh. A party that bases itself on a slightly more gentle fascism isn’t the cart we should be attaching ourselves to.

        It will never ever be the right election for y’all liberal centrists who shit post on left folks. It is always the next one. Point is, if we want to be rid of this fucking fascist shit, we have to build solidarity with the left.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          12
          edit-2
          7 months ago

          Not interested in the whole yelling at each other thing, so genuinely asking here. What exactly does not voting democrat get the left in the US? Is the OP’s assumption that you want to accelerate fascism actually correct?

          So far I haven’t seen any reason other than either accelerationism or “because it makes me feel bad” and I refuse to believe that’s all that’s behind it.

          I’m really having a hard time, and I genuinely think it’s important to try to understand the points of view and beliefs of those we disagree with, rather than immediately turning to infighting.

          • @Maggoty
            link
            27 months ago

            Political parties exist in the free market just like corporations. If they can’t earn votes a new party will form. It’s happened before and it will happen again. That’s why they message with fear. It’s effective at turning off any critical thinking.

            • @PugJesusOP
              link
              English
              -2
              edit-2
              7 months ago

              Political parties exist in the free market just like corporations.

              Tell me more about the political free market under Project 2025.

              In fact, tell me more about how quickly firms rise and fall in the free market. It’s instantaneous, right?

              • @Maggoty
                link
                -17 months ago

                Sometimes it is. Sometimes you have to push it off the cliff.

                • @PugJesusOP
                  link
                  English
                  -47 months ago

                  Sometimes it is.

                  lmao

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            -27 months ago

            Shifts the policies of the Democratic party so that they appeal to leftists. Not going to get into an ongoing debate, but just so you can’t say you haven’t seen any other reasons (which sounds fake to me but okay).

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              5
              edit-2
              7 months ago

              I appreciate it. I’m not here to debate you and I have no reason to lie about not having seen anything else, though I’m honestly a bit hurt that you think that, but I guess you’ve been nothing but attacked so far so perhaps it’s understandable.

            • @apfelwoiSchoppen
              link
              -17 months ago

              Yeah, it is dogpiling and bullying in here. The reasons are here in the comments and elsewhere.

              • @PugJesusOP
                link
                English
                17 months ago

                Bullying is when people say something I don’t like, and the more I don’t like it, the more bullying it is.

                  • @PugJesusOP
                    link
                    English
                    17 months ago

                    Oh good, you’ve asserted that saying something you don’t like is bullying. That truly confirms it, then.

              • @PugJesusOP
                link
                English
                -1
                edit-2
                7 months ago

                Hey, remember when we all protest voted in 2016 and drove the Dem party SO far left?

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  47 months ago

                  Hey, remember when the Dems ran an unlikable centrist candidate as the lesser of two evils because anyone else wasn’t “electable” enough in the DNC’s view of centrist voters, and that translated into an electoral win via pinched noses in 2016? I’m really glad we got a dynastic compromise candidate that saved Democracy. That strategy worked out so well for Hillary, I can see why they’d go for it again.

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  1
                  edit-2
                  7 months ago

                  Barely anyone protest voted lol. She got more votes from Bernie voters than Trump got from Gary Johnson voters. She lost because she didn’t appeal to specific voters in specific states, and the US has a shit democracy that she didn’t correctly strategize for.

                  • @PugJesusOP
                    link
                    English
                    17 months ago

                    Barely anyone protest voted lol.

                    It was the highest 3rd party vote in, what, 20 years?

                    She got more votes from Bernie voters than Trump got from Gary Johnson voters. She lost because she didn’t appeal to specific voters in specific states, and the US has a shit democracy that she didn’t correctly strategize for.

                    Those things are also correct.

                    My point is not “HILLARY COULD HAVE WON” it was “Pretty clearly, despite widespread discontent on the left and the resulting action of witholding votes to either not vote, write-in, or give to the Green/Libertarian Parties, the DNC did not take losing to a right-wing candidate as proof that they needed to move left in any appreciable way”.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              11
              edit-2
              7 months ago

              I can’t tell if you’re mocking me, I don’t know how much clearer I can be that I just want to know why, if I can’t understand why people think it’s a good idea then I can’t be sure that my views/opinions are actually worth anything.

              If you just don’t want to talk to me then, that’s okay too.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              4
              edit-2
              7 months ago

              Is this a bot? This reply doesn’t make any sense.

              What are you agreeing with? They asked you for more information.

              • @apfelwoiSchoppen
                link
                27 months ago

                I was agreeing with not shitting on the left and the need for an attempt to understand them. Not a lot of good faith attempts at understanding happening here, just a lot of bullying.

          • @apfelwoiSchoppen
            link
            4
            edit-2
            7 months ago

            What is ideal about 40 years of two-party neoliberal movement to the right bringing us to the brink of fascism?

            What is privileged about not having healthcare security, job security, in endless war, the environment going to pot, rent exploding, deregulation, ballooning prison numbers, speculative housing markets? Honestly it feels like the privileged who cannot imagine anything different than the bipartisan system that pits us (those on the left and liberals) against each other.

            • @PugJesusOP
              link
              English
              -37 months ago

              Idealism is fun, but it’s so very extremely privileged.

              What is ideal about 40 years of two party neoliberal movement to the right bringing us to the brink of fascism?

              Jesus. At least work on your reading comprehension before responding.

          • @PugJesusOP
            link
            English
            0
            edit-2
            7 months ago

            Idealism is great when you use it to fight for a better world.

            Idealism is privileged when you use it to deny any reduction in harm as not being ‘good enough’ to permit.

            • Sunshine (she/her)
              link
              fedilink
              English
              13 days ago

              Idealism is privileged when you use it to deny any reduction in harm as not being ‘good enough’ to permit.

              It’s happens all the time when people argue against veganism saying that farming kills the animals in the field despite the fact that meat requires much more crop land to produce.

        • @Maggoty
          link
          37 months ago

          He just calls anyone to the left of him a tankie. He has no clue what it actually means.

          • @PugJesusOP
            link
            English
            -57 months ago

            Sorry that I think fascists painted red calling for genocide in America are bad.

            • @Maggoty
              link
              47 months ago

              Oh? Where’s the genocide? Point it out. You guys started this talking point a month ago and nobody has given even an attempt at rationalizing this talking point. You just sound like the guy on the street with a cardboard sign ranting at god. And even better there’s a real one going on right now that Biden is supporting. This wouldn’t be you trying your hand at some Good Old Projection would it?

              • @PugJesusOP
                link
                English
                -67 months ago

                Oh? Where’s the genocide? Point it out.

                Oh, let me get this straight, you’re denying that Trump is genocidal now?

                Please, I want this on record.

                • @Maggoty
                  link
                  27 months ago

                  Show me then. I’m not going to make spurious accusations.

                  • @PugJesusOP
                    link
                    English
                    -77 months ago

                    Show me then.

                    Thank you for confirming that you don’t believe Trump is genocidal. I’ll remember this for future reference. It’s a very common fascist talking point, that their strongman of choice isn’t REALLY genocidal.

        • @PugJesusOP
          link
          English
          -27 months ago

          Never said I was a tankie bruh.

          Didn’t realize that I wasn’t allowed to point out tankie behavior like “Faster fascism Good, Actually” unless the poster self-identified, thank you for the information.

            • @PugJesusOP
              link
              English
              -67 months ago

              “Reason” here being “Make fascism happen faster”

              Forgive me for not finding that a terribly compelling argument.

    • GladiusB
      link
      37 months ago

      Use normal words. You are trying intimidate people with confidence and you just end up not making any sort of point. If we vote the right people in and the right people do their job it isn’t fascist. We aren’t in a fascist regime. You are the only one being “reductive”.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        57 months ago

        The meme oversimplifies what is happening. Our politics has been drifting further to the right with each election and the people in power are fine with that, regardless of whatever party they’re a part of.

        there you go

      • @apfelwoiSchoppen
        link
        1
        edit-2
        7 months ago

        Those are normal words, I apologize for not being the right kind of articulate for you. we have been moving right for 40 plus years. Both parties have been complicit. We fight endless wars under both parties. We have lost access to inexpensive higher education under both parties. We have lost the battle to the healthcare industry under both parties. We have seen the rise of the military police state under both parties. We have become spied on in every facet of life under both parties. Our public infrastructure is falling apart and being deregulated under both parties. We have seen the militarization of our borders under both parties.

        These are real material problems that we continue to ignore with the focus on these two parties. We’ve seen a modicum of progress in certain areas, but there has been a lot of loss of freedom and liberty.

        • GladiusB
          link
          17 months ago

          I disagree. Neoliberalism and foments are not common at all. You can even look it up statistically if you would like. We are not a fascist regime just because you don’t like every decision. That isn’t how fascism works. You still have many freedoms others do not. Is it expensive? Absolutely. Is it fair? No. But there are plenty of Democrats fighting the dumbasses for those rights to become easier. So chill on your “we are in a fascist regime” jargon just because you can’t get every single little thing you want.

          • @apfelwoiSchoppen
            link
            27 months ago

            I said we are moving towards fascism. I never said “we are in a fascist regime”.

            • GladiusB
              link
              4
              edit-2
              7 months ago

              I don’t know if we can discuss how using more words attuned with the audience would help? I think I already said that and you didn’t take kindly to it.

              Foment as much as it could be a synonym for instigate or moving towards as you put it, could also be taken as inspires or motivates an already mobilized force. Maybe it was a poor choice for what you were trying to convey.

    • @Windex007
      link
      -47 months ago

      A meme? REDUCTIVE?

      Jesus. Fucking. Christ.