So this video explains how https works. What I don’t get is what if a hacker in the middle pretended to be the server and provided me with the box and the public key. wouldn’t he be able to decrypt the message with his private key? I’m not a tech expert, but just curious and trying to learn.

  • Cras
    link
    fedilink
    English
    66 months ago

    You don’t really ‘need to’ in a world where a good proportion of people will happily click ‘continue anyway’ when they get any sort of certificate error

    • zeluko
      link
      fedilink
      46 months ago

      Thats why we have HSTS and HSTS preloading, so the browser refuses to allow this (and disabling it is usually alot deeper to find than a simple button to “continue anyways”)

      • @IHawkMike
        link
        English
        26 months ago

        In Chromium browsers you can simply type “thisisunsafe” to bypass even HSTS failures.

    • @NeoNachtwaechter
      link
      English
      16 months ago

      people will happily click ‘continue anyway’

      Not possible without a certificate. There will be no TLS connection, only an error message. No ‘click continue’.

      • ferret
        link
        fedilink
        English
        26 months ago

        It is trivial for an attacker to make self-signed TLS certs, and you can absolutely just click “continue” on sites that use them when you get a warning from the browser

          • Cras
            link
            fedilink
            English
            36 months ago

            Firefox, Chrome, Edge, will all warn you about self-signed certs or cert mismatches but allow you to continue. You’re completely correct that SSL/TLS needs a certificate, but it doesn’t need to be CA issued or in any way legitimate for the encrypted tunnel to be established

          • ferret
            link
            fedilink
            English
            26 months ago

            I am personally using firefox and referencing my own servers that use their own self-signed TLS certs that I have not bothered to load onto my pc because they aren’t public, but chromium-based browsers aren’t some outlier here

            • zeluko
              link
              fedilink
              16 months ago

              Your own servers probably also dont have HSTS enabled, or clicking continue will be disabled (if not overwritten in your browser-config)

              • ferret
                link
                fedilink
                English
                16 months ago

                Reading the HSTS spec, it doesn’t work on first connection, and while most people are using websites they access more than once, that notably isn’t all web use.

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  16 months ago

                  It would be inherently impossible for HSTS to work on first connection, you are correct.

                • zeluko
                  link
                  fedilink
                  16 months ago

                  Indeed, not classically, but there are HSTS preload lists you can put your domain into which will be downloaded by supported browsers.
                  And via HSTS you can include all your subdomains, which would then force proper TLS connections for those you havent visited before too.

                  With the new TLS1.3 version we are getting the HTTPS / “SVCB” Record which not only allows ECH but also indicates to the client similar protection policies like HSTS. (RFC 9460)
                  ECH will then make such attacks impossible on TLS-level, assuming DNSSEC is used and client can make an integrity-checked lookup e.g. via DoH/DoT or validating DnsSec themselves.
                  The strength of this depends on the security-chain you want to follow of course. You dont need DNSSEC, but then the only integrity-check is between DNS-Service and Client if they use DoH/DoT (which is usually enough to defeat local attackers)