• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    214 months ago

    Just a reminder that the only sensible way to determine if a pregnancy was caused by rape is to ask the woman.

    If you’re pro-rape-exception, you’re pro choice.

    • @sandbox
      link
      34 months ago

      I’m pro-choice, but I think this is a bit silly. For example you could say that having car insurance cover accidents but not intentional damage is the same as covering intentional damage because the only sensible way to determine it is to ask the driver.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        64 months ago

        Is it as hard to prove someone intentionally damaged there car as it is to prove someone wasn’t raped? If so, then yes, insurance companies are covering for intentional damage.

        A better fit for your example if is the rules change so that insurance companies only paid out if the other driver intentionally rammed into you. If it was an accident all around they don’t pay out. How would you enforce such a rule? You couldn’t.

        How do you prove sex is consensual when you can’t even demonstrate which sex act caused the pregnancy?

        • @sandbox
          link
          34 months ago

          Requiring a police report of rape would get you over halfway there. And I hate having this conversation because I completely disagree with the idea, but acting like it’s impossible to implement doesn’t help anyone. We should argue against it because it’s a bad idea, not because the enforcement would be tricky.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            3
            edit-2
            4 months ago

            The filing a report becomes paper work to get an abortion.

            Edit: Also, I don’t know if requiring a police report counts as sensible. There are legitimate reasons a woman my not want to file a police report: they don’t want to make trouble with the rapist (boss, parent etc), they were raped by a cop.

            • @sandbox
              link
              14 months ago

              You think they wouldn’t waste a bunch of time looking into it, when it gives them an opportunity to oppress the bodily autonomy of women? C’mon. This is the police we’re talking about.

              Unless they think it’s real, then they won’t bother.

      • @foggy
        link
        14 months ago

        Are you suggesting there is some kind of physical way to determine whether or not intercourse was consensual?

        Allow me to introduce to you Consensual Non-Consent.

        • @sandbox
          link
          24 months ago

          No, I’m saying that if a woman gets pregnant from consensual sexual intercourse with someone and claims that it was rape, it puts her and her partner at risk. This isn’t that difficult.

    • @RestrictedAccount
      link
      24 months ago

      So if a woman wants an abortion, no problem, just lie and send your partner to prison.