It really is, and I admit to grossly oversimplifying it.
I just wish they hadn’t felt the need to insert that line about the weapon going off by accident.
Agreed, though that might have been due to executive meddling (I don’t know, just guessing). Without that, I agree, the moment would have been way better, but it might have been too dark for the time.
OP said they were putting together a discussion post for that later, and I’m totally here for that.
Yup, my understanding is that it was executive meddling.
Apparently there was some disagreement about that scene and a producer insisted that Data wouldn’t kill someone like that, which sounds good in a vacuum but in context makes no sense. Data’s intentions are pretty clear right before he gets transported out, it’s hard to reconcile his actions leading up to the transport with the idea that he wasn’t willing to pull the trigger.
And it’s not like Data never kills people. He carries a phaser for a reason, it’s part of the job. He doesn’t like it (emotion chip shenanigans aside) but he will do what is necessary.
Which, to bring it back around, is part of why this is such an intense scene. A logical being guided by a moral framework that values life looked upon this man and determined that his death was necessary.
It really is, and I admit to grossly oversimplifying it.
Agreed, though that might have been due to executive meddling (I don’t know, just guessing). Without that, I agree, the moment would have been way better, but it might have been too dark for the time.
OP said they were putting together a discussion post for that later, and I’m totally here for that.
Yup, my understanding is that it was executive meddling.
Apparently there was some disagreement about that scene and a producer insisted that Data wouldn’t kill someone like that, which sounds good in a vacuum but in context makes no sense. Data’s intentions are pretty clear right before he gets transported out, it’s hard to reconcile his actions leading up to the transport with the idea that he wasn’t willing to pull the trigger.
And it’s not like Data never kills people. He carries a phaser for a reason, it’s part of the job. He doesn’t like it (emotion chip shenanigans aside) but he will do what is necessary.
Which, to bring it back around, is part of why this is such an intense scene. A logical being guided by a moral framework that values life looked upon this man and determined that his death was necessary.