• @aesthelete
    link
    English
    14 months ago

    Inequality doesn’t just turn up out of nowhere.

    Why would anyone post this? Of course it didn’t just turn up out of nowhere.

    What it is, and what I expect people with a modicum of knowledge of the English language to understand it as, is vaguely gesturing at the overall situation and saying “this thing here that be the way it do”.

    That quoted phrase you have there is pure hot nonsense.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      14 months ago

      Why would anyone post this? Of course it didn’t just turn up out of nowhere.

      Good. Then you agree that it’s valuable to look at the reasons for inequality, I presume, and not stop at “inequality is the centre of it all”. Both material and immaterial ones. Or to put in classic Marxist terms (a bit reductive but it’s close enough): What’s the economic and cultural obstacles to class consciousness.

      That quoted phrase you have there is pure hot nonsense.

      It’s using habitual/continuative aspect. “This thing here that is habitually that way because it habitually is that way”.

      • @aesthelete
        link
        English
        14 months ago

        I know you think you’re the smartest person on Earth giving unthinking Americans lessons or something but you haven’t taught me a damned thing here at all except what the German word for neoliberal is.

        (But, I know, don’t dare call them that!!! 😡🤬 😤)

        😆

        Separately, even frequent users of the habitual be wouldn’t write a sentence like that.