Yes, I’m slow, sorry!
Now this may very well be excessive expectations. I had heard a few people say it’s this year’s Andor. IE, you should just watch it even if it’s not the sort of thing you think you’d be into. Also, I’ve never played the games
I’ve just finished the first 2 episodes, and, for me, it’s not bad, it’s a kinda interesting world … but there’s a distinctly empty feeling and awkwardness to the show for me. Sometimes scenes feel like they’re either filling time or still trying to find their rhythm. I’m not sure any of the dialogue has caught my ear (at all). I’m not sure I’ve picked up on any interesting stakes or mysteries. And I’ve often wondered about the directing (where I can’t help but wonder if Jonathan Nolan’s directing is more about trying to compete with his brother).
The soft tipping point for me was the Knight’s fight with the Ghoul (episode 2) … it just felt pointless and childish. The whole scene seemed to strangely lack any gravity or impetus. And I find myself ~2.5 hrs in and not caring about anything that’s happening. It’s a post nuclear apocalypse world, with some mutants, a naive bunker person, and a manipulative corporation or two doing sneaky shit …
… dunno … what am I missing? Should I just keep watching?
By the end of episode 2 if you’re not into it then I don’t think you’re going to get into it. I mean the big draw about the show really is how well they did with the look and the feel of everything. It just sounds like you don’t appreciate the premise, which is fine not all shows are for everybody.
Thing is, I think I’m rather fond of the general premise, at least as I understand it. I really liked Silo for instance.
I suspect it’s more that I’m completely disconnected from the video game adaptation aspect of it and probably not even into the aesthetic and vibe of a video game adaptation.
“I loved Brokeback Mountain but find these John Wayne movies not to my taste”
Sounds like you like the setting - post apocalyptic - not necessarily the premise. Fallout is about the offbeat humour and violence. Silo is completely different (I loved Silo too).
I know pllllllllenty of people who don’t like Andor. They found it either “too Star Wars-y” or “not Star Wars-y enough”.
The world would be a boring place if we all liked the same things.
I am not at all opposed to offbeat humour and violence! Rather fond of it actually.
The part from the top post I think you’re missing/under-emphasising is my sense that the show feels somewhat empty and awkward. I’m only two episodes in of course, but others in this thread seem to understand where I’m coming from, so I don’t think it’s just a misaligned tastes thing. The season apparently hits its stride as it goes though, so I’ll probably persevere
And I wasn’t suggesting that I was expecting a show just like Andor, from that comparison I was only expecting something surprisingly good. And to be clear, I’m not suggesting it’s a bad show or anything, just sharing how I’m not vibing with it and curious why.
I’ve played the games.
The show sucks - I couldn’t even finish the first episode. There’s no connection to the characters.
Interestingly opposed to others’ impression that game players generally liked the show!
The big thing about the show, and the games is the moral ambiguity of it. It’s captured in a line that maximus says in episode 2? Or 3? Where he says “everyone wants to save the world. They just disagree how to do it.” It’s an important line because everyone has their own way of dealing with the wasteland, which isn’t inherently wrong all the time. And if you watch the ghoul, you’ll see there’s a lot more depth to him than being a comedic psychopath. Give it a little more time and you’ll connect with the characters more. Less so with Lucy, but I think she’s there more as a blank slate, to show how the world can change an otherwise good person.
SILO FUCKIN REPRESENT
ok I’ll shut up now
lol, I’m here for it! I probably like that show too much, but don’t care.