Arctic is a (much) better Lemmy client than any other out there for iOS at least but there are some nifty features for the most recommended app Voyager like the ability to disable side swipes altogether because Apollo’s (reddit) double-tap to upvote for example is much intuitive where side swipes are used to enter and exit communities, posts, comments, menus, settings… or whole app together on Android or Jailbroken devices.

This is my multireddit link after removing u/user which were included as r/_u/redditor from an existing bug to test this for Arctic which would fully enable me along with a lot of us to leave Voyager behind.

  • @Veedem
    link
    English
    -122 days ago

    I’m beginning to think this app is abandoned, man. I don’t expect any features to be added. TestFlight version hasn’t been updated in 2 and a half months.

    • @CreatureSurviveM
      link
      722 days ago

      It’s not dead. I’ve been very busy and have not had the time to work on it recently. I’ve started working on the next update, and I nearly have it ready for the next TestFlight release. I have a dozen or so bugs patched and a few new features done. I’m also hoping to finish up theming support before the next release.

      Next month I should have the time to finish up, and release the MacOS build I’ve been working on, along with improved iPad support.

      Things should start moving here again. I’m hoping to get back to weekly updates here soon.

    • AvieshekOP
      link
      English
      1
      edit-2
      22 days ago

      I like the smoothness and animations from being built natively but these tiny-tiny annoyances everywhere are also irritating at the same time like with swipe gestures mentioned above that can be double-tap and long press instead or the notifications for example doesn’t reset nor receive them at real time and so on…

      • @CreatureSurviveM
        link
        122 days ago

        I keep forgetting to enable clearing notifications when reading them in app. I added this feature, but had it disabled for testing. Thank you for reminding me.

        As for real-time notification, this is just not possible yet due to API limitations. If they add support for web hooks in the future, then I will add real-time notifications. But currently the only way to get notifications is to request them from the instance. Im already fetching notifications once a minute for each account with notifications enabled. This translates to a lot of network traffic for instances, and I do not want to increase that beyond what it is currently.

        • AvieshekOP
          link
          English
          1
          edit-2
          22 days ago

          What I really meant is push notifications, like there are no banners, badges or alerts of any kind until the app is actually opened even though all permissions are granted: Notification Settings

          There’s also another issue I happen to come across when uploading a media, probably another bug but there was no way to exit this screen unless forcefully closing the app: Uploading… Please change the interface that allows to dismiss with a cancel button so one doesn’t have to start all over again if they’re writing a comment.

          Looks like this happens when permission to select more images is about to be granted but it skips to upload instead for the first time per new image: Again…

          • @CreatureSurviveM
            link
            120 days ago
            1. This is a strange one, I have not received any reports of this behavior until now. I did restart the notification server today to see if that may resolve this issue, but I will be taking larger look into this during the week to see if I can’t find what might be causing this. In the meantime, could you try disabling and re-enabling the notifications in arctic to see if that resolves the issue?

            2. I will definitely add an option to cancel media uploads, this was a poor design choice on my part, I should have included a cancel feature from the start.

            3. You are absolutely right, this has to do with granting access to new images, I managed to resolve this for the next update. Limited access makes things a little more complicated than it should be. Now with limited access, Arctic will ask you to grant access to new photos before asking to choose new photos to upload. This can be configured in Arctics settings to ask about granting access before each upload, or only doing so once per app session.

            • AvieshekOP
              link
              English
              1
              edit-2
              18 days ago
              1. I reinstalled the app fresh even and now on your TestFlight but couldn’t really figure out myself here. However, I tried going to accounts > profile and manually enable the push notification toggle which led to a spam of sound notifications with lockscreen being lit up every five seconds for the same notification until being turned off, the app crashed on the TestFlight version when hitting the Report Issue button under ⚙️ and continues to be the case even now.
              2. No disagreements here but I have noticed bullet lists can break inside Arctic app when using paragraph spacing. It’s fine in lemmy.world site but on the reddit iOS client for example one can hit return (enter) while pressing the shift button to introduce paragraph breaks inside the bullets and numbering just like the desktop site.
              3. I applaud your understanding on this issue but if am not mistaking this wrong then instead of having to toggle within the settings layer again, just integrate having to choose & allow together when attaching a new image unless all permission is granted from iOS Settings like in other apps. One thing I would like to ask is will it be possible to attach media outside of Photos app (as from anywhere - Files app for example) like in macOS? Also, for media attachments… can they be shown exactly where it’s mentioned instead of collecting in the bottom? Not sure why caption is necessary for each upload but the images can be above those captions that are forced to fill anyway so it maintains the flow of relevance.
              • @CreatureSurviveM
                link
                118 days ago
                1. This is odd. I’ll have to look into this. Notifications have been working fine for the last year, but I received 2 reports about this issue this week. I’ll try and track this down tonight.
                2. I made some improvements to the bullet lists the other day, they will now have spacing between items in the list. For multiple paragraphs in list items, I’ll have to look into this, because you are right that they do not render correctly. All the text rendering in Arctic is completely custom, so it’s no surprise that missed some features. I will look into this though and try to find a solution.
                3. It seems that iOS changed some things with the image picker, and it’s no longer necessary to ask for photos access permission when selecting a photo. I’m going to look into this and see if I can’t simplify things for limited access. It’s definitely not ideal to have to select photos twice.
                4. As for displaying photos in-line, this is something that I’ve wanted to do for a while now, as currently any photos are just appended below the comment text. Like I said, the text rendering in Arctic is completely custom and this is a bit of a tricky task even though it may seem simple. For instance Apollo never managed to implement this either. IOS does support showing images in text views, though this would not work for gifs or videos due to limitations. I finally managed to get something working for this yesterday, and it’s now possible to display images or videos in-line. I do not have this fully implemented yet, as it does cause some text rendering issues that I’ll need to fix. I should definitely have this fully working here soon though. Also, with this new feature I should be able to improve support for spoilers and markdown tables using the same technique.
                • AvieshekOP
                  link
                  English
                  1
                  edit-2
                  18 days ago

                  Regarding Numbered List: While making a response, the numbering stays right during editing mode - something to take note of that it can be fixed as I would be looking forward to subnumbered list like 1.1 → 1.2 next, instead of just 1 → 2

                  Here’s reddit markdown wiki which is a good reference to bookmark for across all internet to follow in a synchronised manner.
                  ↳ Personally, I would restrict italics to only _italics_ and bold to *bold*

                  One thing however I don’t understand is the nature of spoiler here as opposed to anywhere else including reddit itself, the one on Lemmy is more like collapsible menu items than a spoiler. If you’re fixing the spoiler back to normal then I would request to rename the current spoiler system to something else which is good for sidebar rules but not really as a spoiler itself in comments.


                  >!spoiler!<


                  ::: menu Title Text :::


                  Looking forward to the changes. ✌︎

                  ^Also, looks like link previews have the same problem as images.^

                  • @CreatureSurviveM
                    link
                    118 days ago

                    I would love to do this, because you are right, the spoilers in Lemmy do not function the same as spoilers on any other platform. However I can’t add this as a feature since it would only be supported in Arctic and people browsing on desktop or any other client would not would not have support for this. So until Lemmy officially supports in-line spoilers like Reddit, we will have to make do with the current system.

                    It doesn’t make sense to allow composing posts or comments that could only be properly viewed in Arctic.

                  • @CreatureSurviveM
                    link
                    118 days ago

                    Lemmy as well as most of the Fediverse uses the CommonMark Specification any markdown features I add will either be supported by CommonMark or by Lemmy. I do not want to create a a new specification, or use the Reddit specification unless it is adopted by Lemmy.

                    CommonMark does not support decimal numbers lists, so this is not an option as it would break list rendering on every other client. You have to remember that Lemmy is federated unlike Reddit. Users may be reading in a different app, on desktop, or even on a different platform like Mastodon. Changes like these need to be widely accepted and it would do more harm than good to implement breaking changes in Arctic that would not work correctly anywhere else.

                    Same goes for spoilers, and restricting italic markers. If these features do not meet the standard, then they will just cause harm.

                    As for in-line link previews. I’m not sure about this one. Most links are posted in context, like the middle of a sentence or paragraph. Putting previews in the middle like that would decrease readability. That’s partially why I treat them similar to footnotes and link them at the bottom of the context.

                    With that said I could add soupy for this, but it would be an optional feature that would be off by default.