I love horror but apparently I don’t vibe with a lot of recommendations I find online.

I’d seen so much hype about Event Horizon and I absolutely hated it and didn’t find it scary. I just watched Late Night With the Devil and whole it was definitely enjoyable, it wasn’t the least but frightening. I also just watched Let the Right One In and really didn’t like it. It also was not a horror movie in my opinion.

I will say one of my favorites is Sinister or the first Conjuring. Sinister for the stomach twisting dread and suspence throughout and Conjuring for the same.

So, what movies do you find to be the scariest?

  • @Suck_on_my_PresenceOP
    3•3 months ago
    • The Exorcist (The Version You’ve Never Seen)

    I’ve never seen this version? But I have read the book and eugh. It’s horrible in a sort of losing bodily autonomy way.

    • Hereditary (a masterpiece in my opinion. Free upvote literally every time I see someone recommend it)

    This one sat with me for a long time and I swore immediately after watching it that I would never watch it again. And now I absolutely love it. There are a few bright moments that really freak me out, but the tension and build up is so good. Chef’s kiss to this one.

    • Blair Witch Project

    Haven’t seen!

    • Paranormal Activity

    One of my favorites! I know this one gets dragged for being campy(??), but I think the original did an excellent job of building suspense and dread.

    • Ouija: Origin of Evil

    Mike Flanagan is one of my favorites and this one is a lot of fun. Not as high in my list as others, but still a good time.

    • It (miniseries got me as a kid but Chapter 1 is good too)

    I need to rewatch the miniseries, but I wasn’t a huge fan of the more recent movies. I think the actors were all great (especially for Pennywise), but it felt like it was trying too hard? Pt 2 seemed to realize they’d never match the book and it ended up being more funny than anything.

    • Lights Out (not the entire movie but it has its moments and overall a good style)
    • Candyman (original)
    • Poltergeist (original)
    • Autopsy of Jane Doe (another poster reminded me of this one!)
    • The Taking of Deborah Logan (for like one scene but IYKYK)
    • The Dark and the Wicked
    • The Orphanage
    • Terrified and When Evil Lurks were both solidly unsettling at least

    These are all being added to my list!

    • Event Horizon (though I know you didn’t like this one)

    Bleh. Lol

    • Conjuring 1-2 and Sinister too, all at least solid spookies.

    Love these movies. I would add the first half of Insidious as well.

    As for my list - I’ll throw that in a separate comment soon enough :D

    • @EvilBit
      2•3 months ago

      Wow you have some fun ahead of you. And from what you’ve said, despite a few (strong) disagreements, I think you have great taste.

      The Exorcist Version You’ve Never Seen just adds some deleted scenes back into the mix. A common complaint is that it escalates too quickly as a result, but damn if it didn’t stick with me.

      Blair Witch is a real divisive one but if it hits, it hits RIGHT.

      Paranormal Activity is in my pantheon of game changers. It’s not perfect (Micah can fuck off forever please) but the way it established the day/night safe/scary cycle only to violate it at the end was a master stroke.

      Ouija is just the best creepy Flanagan film for me, but I think my favorite of his is actually Oculus. I love that it’s legitimately trying to avoid the pitfall of dying from dumb decisions by starting off with “let’s study the shit out of this evil”. I also adore Doctor Sleep and Haunting of Hill House.

      The It miniseries scared the hell out of me as a child so I can’t promise it’ll be as good now. I thought Chapter 1 was really solid and creepy but the second one dropped the ball really hard.